Shahar Danit R, Henkin Yaakov, Rozen Geila S, Adler Dorit, Levy Orna, Safra Carmit, Itzhak Baruch, Golan Rachel, Shai Iris
S Daniel Abraham International Center for Health and Nutrition, Ben-Gurion University, Beer-Sheva, Israel.
Nutrition. 2009 May;25(5):532-9. doi: 10.1016/j.nut.2008.11.020. Epub 2009 Feb 20.
Data regarding health providers' personal lifestyle and the differential effect of a short-term personal lifestyle experience intervention program on health providers are limited.
We conducted a controlled study aimed at changing personal attitudes toward lifestyle habits among 323 health professionals: 136 (42%) physicians, 140 (43%) dietitians, and 47 (15%) nurses and health promoters. In the intervention group (n = 209) individuals participated in a 2-d intensive self-experience workshop in an isolated location emphasizing healthy lifestyle and behavior-modifying techniques. Intervention and control groups were followed for 6 mo.
At baseline, avoidance of salt, trans-fatty acids, saturated fats, and processed meat was more frequent among dietitians (P < 0.05 versus physicians). The physicians reported a lower intake of olive/canola oil, nuts/almonds, dietary fibers, vegetables, and fruits (P < 0.05). Furthermore, physicians reported lower confidence in lifestyle primary prevention and felt less useful engaging in health-promotion activities (P < 0.05 versus other health professionals). After 6 mo, waist circumference decreased in the intervention group (-1.3 versus +1.8 cm in control group, P < 0.01). The effect was more prominent among physicians. A modest differential effect of the intervention program was shown in health-promotion activities.
Approaches toward primary prevention can be improved by an intervention program focusing on personal changes of health care providers. Physicians who are less likely to personally adhere to and believe in lifestyle primary prevention are more likely to benefit from this platform.
关于医疗服务提供者个人生活方式以及短期个人生活方式体验干预项目对医疗服务提供者的差异影响的数据有限。
我们进行了一项对照研究,旨在改变323名医疗专业人员对生活方式习惯的个人态度,其中包括136名(42%)医生、140名(43%)营养师以及47名(15%)护士和健康促进者。干预组(n = 209)的个体在一个偏远地点参加了为期2天的强化自我体验工作坊,该工作坊强调健康的生活方式和行为改变技巧。对干预组和对照组进行了6个月的随访。
在基线时,营养师中避免摄入盐、反式脂肪酸、饱和脂肪和加工肉类的情况更为常见(与医生相比,P < 0.05)。医生报告橄榄油/菜籽油、坚果/杏仁、膳食纤维、蔬菜和水果的摄入量较低(P < 0.05)。此外,医生报告在生活方式一级预防方面的信心较低,并且感觉参与健康促进活动的作用较小(与其他医疗专业人员相比,P < 0.05)。6个月后,干预组的腰围减小(对照组为+1.8 cm,干预组为-1.3 cm,P < 0.01)。这种效果在医生中更为显著。干预项目在健康促进活动中显示出适度的差异影响。
通过关注医疗保健提供者个人改变的干预项目,可以改善一级预防的方法。不太可能亲自坚持并相信生活方式一级预防的医生更有可能从这个平台中受益。