Bourgeois Pierre, Leduc Oliver, Belgrado Jean-Pol, Leduc Albert
Service of Nuclear Medicine, Institut Jules Bordet, Université Libre de Bruxelles, Brussels, Belgium.
Nucl Med Commun. 2009 Apr;30(4):270-4. doi: 10.1097/MNM.0b013e32831bec4d.
Both subcutaneous and intradermal injections are used for the scintigraphic investigations of the superficial lymphatic system. The qualitative differences between these types of injections are well known. This study quantified their differences in a group of volunteers.
With the limbs at rest, activities in the axillary nodes (AxN) were recorded at 1, 20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 min after subcutaneous or intradermal injection of TC-labelled human serum albumin nanocolloids in the ventral middle part of each forearm of nine young, healthy, male volunteers and the results were compared.
Expressed as per 10,000 of injected activity, activities recorded in the AxN were significantly higher (32.5 times as a mean value, ranging from 8.4 to 130.7 times) after intradermal injections than after subcutaneous injections (P<0.001 by using two-tailed Wilcoxon's signed-rank test). The mean AxN activity after intradermal injections was also apparently higher for the right limbs than for the left limbs, but when the paired t-test was used to compare the right with the left values of the nine volunteers, the comparison did not reach statistical significance (at T+100, 2P=0.087). When their handedness is taken into account, however, a level of statistical significance is reached (at T+100, 2P=0.025).
This study quantifies the differences between subcutaneous and intradermal injections, but also shows, although on a limited number of volunteers, that handedness influences the results of the intradermal injections.
皮下注射和皮内注射均用于浅表淋巴系统的闪烁显像研究。这两种注射方式的定性差异是众所周知的。本研究在一组志愿者中对它们的差异进行了量化。
在九名年轻、健康的男性志愿者每只前臂腹侧中部皮下或皮内注射锝标记的人血清白蛋白纳米胶体后,让其肢体处于休息状态,分别在1、20、40、60、80和100分钟记录腋窝淋巴结(AxN)的活性,并对结果进行比较。
以每10000注射活性表示,皮内注射后AxN记录的活性显著高于皮下注射后(平均值为32.5倍,范围为8.4至130.7倍)(采用双尾Wilcoxon符号秩检验,P<0.001)。皮内注射后右上肢的AxN平均活性也明显高于左上肢,但当使用配对t检验比较九名志愿者的右上肢和左上肢数值时,该比较未达到统计学显著性(在T + 100时,2P = 0.087)。然而,考虑到他们的利手情况时,则达到了一定的统计学显著性水平(在T + 100时,2P = 0.025)。
本研究量化了皮下注射和皮内注射之间的差异,但也表明,尽管志愿者数量有限,但利手会影响皮内注射的结果。