Jovanović Gordana
Passau Schr Psychologiegesch. 2005;13:211-24.
When Freud began formulating the basic postulates of psychoanalytic theory the concept of instinct was in widespread use. There are very different models of conceptualizing instincts in psychoanalysis: reflex arc, representation, interaction, subject and finally a regressive structure. Freud revised the traditional concept of instinct and his models formed a peculiar metatheoretical history of psychoanalysis. Defining human nature by reference to its determining instinctive essence and commitment to the ideal of natural science led Freud to a naturalistic fallacy. Yet at the same time the hermeneutics of instinct theory reveal a socio-historical meaning of naturalism.
当弗洛伊德开始阐述精神分析理论的基本假设时,本能的概念已被广泛使用。在精神分析中,存在着非常不同的本能概念化模型:反射弧、表征、互动、主体,最后是一种退行性结构。弗洛伊德修正了传统的本能概念,他的模型构成了精神分析独特的元理论历史。通过参考其决定性的本能本质来定义人性,并致力于自然科学的理想,这使弗洛伊德陷入了自然主义谬误。然而,与此同时,本能理论的诠释学揭示了自然主义的社会历史意义。