Tieu M M
Southern Cross Bioethics Institute, North Plympton, South Australia.
J Med Ethics. 2009 Mar;35(3):171-5. doi: 10.1136/jme.2008.024679.
One of the major concerns about surrogacy is the potential harm that may be inflicted upon the surrogate mother and the child after relinquishment. Even if one were to take the liberal view that surrogacy should be presumptively allowed on the basis of autonomy and/or compassion, evidence of harm must be taken seriously. In this paper I review the evidence from psychological studies on the effect that relinquishing a child has on the surrogate mother and while it appears that many surrogates are able to cope with relinquishment, I argue that there are good reasons, grounded in empirical evidence, to support the view that the subsequent management of the relinquishment necessarily objectifies the surrogate mother.
代孕引发的一个主要担忧是,代孕女性在放弃孩子监护权后,自身及孩子可能遭受的潜在伤害。即便有人持自由主义观点,认为基于自主性和/或同情心,代孕原则上应被允许,但伤害的证据也必须得到认真对待。在本文中,我回顾了心理学研究中关于放弃孩子对代孕女性影响的证据。虽然许多代孕女性似乎能够应对放弃孩子监护权的情况,但我认为,基于实证证据,有充分理由支持这样一种观点,即后续对放弃监护权的处理必然会将代孕女性物化。