Wheeler-Kingshott Claudia A M, Cercignani Mara
University College London, Institute of Neurology, Department of Neuroinflammation, London, UK.
Magn Reson Med. 2009 May;61(5):1255-60. doi: 10.1002/mrm.21965.
This article presents the potential problems arising from the use of "axial" and "radial" diffusivities, derived from the eigenvalues of the diffusion tensor, and their interpretation in terms of the underlying biophysical properties, such as myelin and axonal density. Simulated and in vivo data are shown. The simulations demonstrate that a change in "radial" diffusivity can cause a fictitious change in "axial" diffusivity and vice versa in voxels characterized by crossing fibers. The in vivo data compare the direction of the principle eigenvector in four different subjects, two healthy and two affected by multiple sclerosis, and show that the angle, alpha, between the principal eigenvectors of corresponding voxels of registered datasets is greater than 45 degrees in areas of low anisotropy, severe pathology, and partial volume. Also, there are areas of white matter pathology where the "radial" diffusivity is 10% greater than that of the corresponding normal tissue and where the direction of the principal eigenvector is altered by more than 45 degrees compared to the healthy case. This should strongly discourage researchers from interpreting changes of the "axial" and "radial" diffusivities on the basis of the underlying tissue structure, unless accompanied by a thorough investigation of their mathematical and geometrical properties in each dataset studied.
本文介绍了由扩散张量的特征值得出的“轴向”和“径向”扩散率的使用所产生的潜在问题,以及它们根据诸如髓磷脂和轴突密度等潜在生物物理特性的解释。展示了模拟数据和体内数据。模拟结果表明,在存在交叉纤维的体素中,“径向”扩散率的变化会导致“轴向”扩散率出现虚拟变化,反之亦然。体内数据比较了四名不同受试者(两名健康受试者和两名患有多发性硬化症的受试者)中主特征向量的方向,结果表明,在各向异性较低、病变严重和存在部分容积的区域,配准数据集相应体素的主特征向量之间的夹角α大于45度。此外,在白质病变区域,“径向”扩散率比相应正常组织大10%,且与健康情况相比,主特征向量的方向改变超过45度。这应强烈劝阻研究人员在未对所研究的每个数据集中的数学和几何特性进行全面调查的情况下,基于基础组织结构来解释“轴向”和“径向”扩散率的变化。