Voeller G R, Bunch G, Britt L G
Department of Surgery, University of Tennessee, Memphis 38163.
Surgery. 1991 Oct;110(4):799-804.
The effectiveness of technetium 99m-labeled red blood cell scintigraphy in localizing hemorrhage, directing surgical intervention, and screening patients for arteriography was determined in 103 patients. The radionuclide scan result was compared to the bleeding site determined by arteriography, endoscopy, or surgery. Eighty-five patients had a bleeding site identified; 18 patients did not and were excluded. Thirty-one scans were performed in 29 patients for upper gastrointestinal hemorrhage. Five positive scans incorrectly localized an upper gastrointestinal bleeding site, although two scans localized the site, for a scan sensitivity of 8%. Fifty-nine scans were performed in 56 patients with lower gastrointestinal bleeding. Fifteen scans were positive, three incorrectly localizing the hemorrhage. Seventy-four percent of the patients with lower gastrointestinal hemorrhage documented by arteriography, endoscopy, or surgery had negative scans for bleeding. The radionuclide scan sensitivity for lower gastrointestinal bleeding was 23%. Surgery was required in 18 patients for bleeding, 11 of whom had negative scans for bleeding. In seven surgical patients with positive scans, in no instance did the scan direct the surgical intervention. Eighteen patients underwent scintigraphy and arteriography; nearly one half of the patients with negative scans for bleeding had positive localizing arteriograms, although almost one half of the patients with positive scans for bleeding had negative arteriograms. Scintigraphy failed to localize hemorrhage in 85% of the patients. Technetium 99m-labeled red blood cell scintigraphy did not direct surgical intervention, nor did it adequately screen patients for arteriography.
在103例患者中确定了锝99m标记的红细胞闪烁扫描术在定位出血、指导手术干预以及筛选患者进行动脉造影方面的有效性。将放射性核素扫描结果与通过动脉造影、内镜检查或手术确定的出血部位进行比较。85例患者确定了出血部位;18例患者未确定出血部位并被排除。对29例上消化道出血患者进行了31次扫描。5次阳性扫描错误地定位了上消化道出血部位,尽管有2次扫描定位到了出血部位,扫描敏感性为8%。对56例下消化道出血患者进行了59次扫描。15次扫描呈阳性,3次错误地定位了出血部位。经动脉造影、内镜检查或手术证实有下消化道出血的患者中,74%的扫描结果为出血阴性。下消化道出血的放射性核素扫描敏感性为23%。18例患者因出血需要手术,其中11例扫描结果为出血阴性。在7例扫描呈阳性的手术患者中,扫描均未指导手术干预。18例患者接受了闪烁扫描和动脉造影;几乎一半出血扫描阴性的患者动脉造影定位阳性,而几乎一半出血扫描阳性的患者动脉造影阴性。闪烁扫描未能在85%的患者中定位出血部位。锝99m标记的红细胞闪烁扫描术既未指导手术干预,也未充分筛选患者进行动脉造影。