Duboeuf François, Basarab Adrian, Liebgott Hervé, Brusseau Elisabeth, Delachartre Philippe, Vray Didier
CREATIS-LRMN, INSA-Lyon, UCB Lyon 1, Université de Lyon, CNRS UMR 5220, INSERM U 630, 69621 Villeurbanne, France.
Med Phys. 2009 Feb;36(2):656-61. doi: 10.1118/1.3065031.
We describe a quasistatic method for mechanical characterization of tissue-mimicking material used in elastography. We demonstrate that it is possible to assess the elasticity modulus with a reasonable reproducibility using simple and easy tools and methods. Possessing a simple relevant technique with evaluated relative error to assess Young's modulus of these phantoms could deeply improve the quality of the research in the field of elastography. The method was tested and validated with four samples of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) cryogel with different elasticity values corresponding to those of stiffer soft biological tissues. Young's moduli, varying from 70 to 180 kPa depending on the number of freeze-thaw cycles (two to five), were measured within strict measurement conditions and found to have a reproducibility varying from 4% to 8%. Relative error, estimated as the ratio between observed and reference values, varied from 16% to 32%. Besides, measurement stability over 4 months was evaluated. The method demonstrated good feasibility and acceptable reproducibility for mechanically characterizing and controlled over time phantoms used for validating new potential ultrasound imaging techniques in the field of elastography. Nevertheless, in this study, investigation was performed on gel possessing young's modulus values ranging from 80 to 215 kPa. Some tissue values of Young'modulus were reported to be lower, ranging from 0.6 to 28 kPa as liver or glandular values. Consequently, further validation of this static method for mechanical characterization of phantom gels should be performed using softer PVA cryogel.
我们描述了一种用于弹性成像中组织模拟材料力学特性表征的准静态方法。我们证明,使用简单易行的工具和方法,可以以合理的可重复性评估弹性模量。拥有一种具有评估相对误差的简单相关技术来评估这些体模的杨氏模量,可以极大地提高弹性成像领域的研究质量。该方法用四个具有不同弹性值的聚乙烯醇(PVA)冷冻凝胶样品进行了测试和验证,这些弹性值对应于较硬的软生物组织。在严格的测量条件下,测量了杨氏模量,其值根据冻融循环次数(2至5次)在70至180 kPa之间变化,发现其可重复性在4%至8%之间。相对误差估计为观测值与参考值之比,在16%至32%之间变化。此外,还评估了4个月内的测量稳定性。该方法对于用于验证弹性成像领域新的潜在超声成像技术的体模的力学特性表征和随时间的控制具有良好的可行性和可接受的可重复性。然而,在本研究中,对杨氏模量值在80至215 kPa之间的凝胶进行了研究。据报道,一些组织的杨氏模量值较低,如肝脏或腺体的值在0.6至28 kPa之间。因此,应使用更软的PVA冷冻凝胶对这种用于体模凝胶力学特性表征的静态方法进行进一步验证。