Wysowski D K, Barash D
Division of Epidemiology and Surveillance, Food and Drug Administration, Rockville, Md.
Arch Intern Med. 1991 Oct;151(10):2003-8.
Reports of adverse behavioral reactions to triazolam, a triazolobenzodiazepine ultra-short-acting hypnotic, were examined in the postmarketing surveillance Spontaneous Reporting System of the Food and Drug Administration. Reports for triazolam of confusion, amnesia, bizarre behavior, agitation, and hallucinations were compared with reports of these reactions for temazepam, another short-acting hypnotic. Analysis of individual case reports from marketing through 1985 for triazolam vs temazepam showed 133 vs two for confusion, 109 vs three for amnesia, 59 vs two for bizarre behavior, 58 vs four for agitation, and 40 vs one for hallucinations. Considering extent of use, reporting rates for triazolam were 22 to 99 times those for temazepam, depending on the reaction. Reactions to triazolam tended to occur at higher doses and in older patients. This and an updated analysis of aggregate reports for the first 7 years of marketing of each drug with reporting rates and adjustment for various factors suggest a higher occurrence of these reactions with triazolam, but selection factors cannot be completely ruled out. When treating insomnia, physicians should emphasize sleep hygiene practices as alternatives to drug therapy; if drug therapy is required, they should prescribe hypnotics at the lowest recommended doses for the shortest clinically necessary durations and discontinue medication use should any adverse reactions occur.
在食品药品监督管理局的上市后监测自发报告系统中,对三唑仑(一种三唑并苯二氮䓬超短效催眠药)的不良行为反应报告进行了审查。将三唑仑有关意识模糊、失忆、怪异行为、激动和幻觉的报告与另一种短效催眠药替马西泮的这些反应报告进行了比较。对1985年之前上市以来三唑仑与替马西泮的个案报告分析显示,意识模糊方面分别为133例和2例,失忆方面分别为109例和3例,怪异行为方面分别为59例和2例,激动方面分别为58例和4例,幻觉方面分别为40例和1例。考虑到使用范围,三唑仑的报告率是替马西泮的22至99倍,具体取决于反应类型。三唑仑的反应往往发生在较高剂量时以及老年患者中。这一点以及对每种药物上市后前7年汇总报告的更新分析(包括报告率以及对各种因素的调整)表明,三唑仑发生这些反应的几率更高,但不能完全排除选择因素。治疗失眠时,医生应强调睡眠卫生措施作为药物治疗的替代方法;如果需要药物治疗,他们应开具最低推荐剂量的催眠药,使用时间为临床上最短的必要时长,并且一旦出现任何不良反应应停止用药。