Crawford Cassandra S
Department of Sociology, Northern Illinois University, DeKalb, 60115, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2009 Sep;69(5):655-61. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2009.02.022. Epub 2009 Mar 18.
In opposition to the argument that pain is private, personal and unsharable, I propose that the intersubjectivity of pain is fundamental to it. Using the case of phantom limb, I show how a specific language of pain emerged and became concretized in the US circa 1975 with the advent of the McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ). Through widespread use of the MPQ, a language of pain materialized, one that was commonly used to describe the qualitative dimensions of phantom limb. After 1975, the terminology used within the medical literature was overwhelmingly consonant with the set of descriptors advanced by the MPQ. The utilization of a pain questionnaire to assess the qualitative dimensions of phantom limb effectively accentuated pain, and by 1980, what was once considered relatively rare became a common sequela of phantom manifestation.
与疼痛是私密、个人且不可共享的观点相反,我认为疼痛的主体间性是其根本所在。以幻肢为例,我展示了大约在1975年美国随着麦吉尔疼痛问卷(MPQ)的出现,一种特定的疼痛语言是如何出现并具体化的。通过MPQ的广泛使用,一种疼痛语言得以形成,这种语言常用于描述幻肢的质性维度。1975年之后,医学文献中使用的术语与MPQ提出的描述符集绝大多数是一致的。使用疼痛问卷来评估幻肢的质性维度有效地突出了疼痛,到1980年,曾经被认为相对罕见的情况成为了幻肢表现的常见后遗症。