Het S, Rohleder N, Schoofs D, Kirschbaum C, Wolf O T
Department of Cognitive Psychology, Ruhr-University Bochum, Germany.
Psychoneuroendocrinology. 2009 Aug;34(7):1075-86. doi: 10.1016/j.psyneuen.2009.02.008.
The "Trier Social Stress Test" (TSST) is one of the most prominent laboratory stress paradigms. It is often used to investigate the effects of stress on cognitive or affective parameters. Such studies need a non-stress control condition. However, control conditions currently employed are often rather ill defined and do not parallel important modulating variables, e.g., physical or cognitive load of the TSST. We here introduce a placebo version of the TSST, which contains a free speech and a simple mental arithmetic task without uncontrollability and social-evaluative threat. In two studies, this control condition was evaluated using salivary markers of stress reactivity (cortisol and alpha-amylase) and a questionnaire for anticipatory cognitive stress appraisal (PASA). In experiment 1 participants who were treated with the placebo condition showed no cortisol response and a small, but significant salivary alpha-amylase (sAA) response. Both responses were significantly smaller than those of TSST-treated participants. The placebo-treated participants also rated the treatment situation as less stressful. In experiment 2 a crossover study with the use of an intercom to instruct the participants and ensure their compliance was conducted. Again there was a strong cortisol response to the TSST, which differed significantly from the cortisol levels observed during the placebo condition. Importantly the cortisol response was not influenced by treatment order (TSST or placebo first). However, in this study we found similar reactions between TSST- and placebo-treated participants with regard to sAA-response. We suggest that the introduced placebo protocol for the TSST is a promising tool for future psychobiological research. The exact procedure for a given experiment should be tailored to the specific needs of the empirical question studied.
“特里尔社会应激测试”(TSST)是最著名的实验室应激范式之一。它常被用于研究应激对认知或情感参数的影响。此类研究需要一个非应激对照条件。然而,目前所采用的对照条件往往定义不明确,且与重要的调节变量不匹配,例如TSST的身体或认知负荷。我们在此引入TSST的安慰剂版本,其中包含一个自由发言和一个简单的心算任务,且不存在不可控性和社会评价威胁。在两项研究中,使用应激反应的唾液标志物(皮质醇和α-淀粉酶)以及一份预期认知应激评估问卷(PASA)对这个对照条件进行了评估。在实验1中,接受安慰剂条件处理的参与者未表现出皮质醇反应,但唾液α-淀粉酶(sAA)有一个小而显著的反应。这两种反应均显著小于接受TSST处理的参与者的反应。接受安慰剂处理的参与者也将处理情境评定为压力较小。在实验2中,进行了一项交叉研究,使用对讲机指导参与者并确保他们的依从性。同样,对TSST有强烈的皮质醇反应,这与在安慰剂条件下观察到的皮质醇水平有显著差异。重要的是,皮质醇反应不受处理顺序(先进行TSST或先进行安慰剂处理)的影响。然而,在这项研究中,我们发现接受TSST处理和接受安慰剂处理的参与者在sAA反应方面有相似的反应。我们认为,所引入的TSST安慰剂方案是未来心理生物学研究的一个有前景的工具。给定实验的确切程序应根据所研究实证问题的具体需求进行调整。