Hallett Jonathan, Maycock Bruce, Kypri Kypros, Howat Peter, McManus Alexandra
WA Centre for Health Promotion Research, Curtin University, Perth, Australia.
Drug Alcohol Rev. 2009 Jan;28(1):31-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1465-3362.2008.00008.x.
Despite growing evidence of the efficacy of electronic screening and brief interventions for reducing unhealthy alcohol use, there is no published work describing the development of such interventions. We describe the process of developing and implementing an electronic screening and brief intervention in a large university population.
Thematic analysis of seven focus groups, involving a total of 69 students, informed the content and design of THRIVE (Tertiary Health Research Intervention Via Email). Pilot testing was conducted through usability analysis with a further 16 students. A random sample of 13,000 undergraduates was invited to complete screening and hazardous drinkers were randomised to receive Web-based assessment and feedback or screening alone. Participants' use of THRIVE was examined through server log analysis and responses to questions on instrument design/usability during follow-up assessment 6 months later.
A total of 7237 students (56% of those invited) completed screening; 2435 (34%) screened positive for unhealthy drinking; 1251 were randomly assigned to receive the intervention; and 1184 served as controls. In total, 99% of participants found THRIVE easy to complete, 76% said it provided personally relevant information and 55% said they would recommend it to a friend with a drinking problem. Thirty per cent sought additional information on support services through the site.
Key design elements include ease of access (e.g. via an emailed hyperlink), length (<10 min), clear, non-judgmental language, personalised normative feedback and links to appropriate services. The study demonstrates the potential reach of a carefully implemented intervention in a high-risk, non-treatment-seeking population group.
尽管越来越多的证据表明电子筛查和简短干预在减少有害饮酒方面具有有效性,但尚无已发表的作品描述此类干预措施的开发过程。我们描述了在一大群大学生中开发和实施电子筛查及简短干预的过程。
对七个焦点小组(共69名学生)进行主题分析,为THRIVE(通过电子邮件进行的高等健康研究干预)的内容和设计提供了依据。通过对另外16名学生进行可用性分析来进行试点测试。邀请了13000名本科生的随机样本完成筛查,危险饮酒者被随机分配接受基于网络的评估和反馈或仅接受筛查。通过服务器日志分析以及6个月后随访评估期间对仪器设计/可用性问题的回答,来检查参与者对THRIVE的使用情况。
共有7237名学生(占受邀者的56%)完成了筛查;2435名(34%)筛查出有害饮酒呈阳性;1251名被随机分配接受干预;1184名作为对照。总体而言,99%的参与者认为THRIVE易于完成,76%的人表示它提供了与个人相关的信息,55%的人表示会将其推荐给有饮酒问题的朋友。30%的人通过该网站寻求有关支持服务的更多信息。
关键设计要素包括易于访问(例如通过电子邮件中的超链接)、时长(<10分钟)、清晰、无偏见的语言、个性化的规范反馈以及指向适当服务的链接。该研究表明,在高风险、未寻求治疗的人群中精心实施的干预措施具有潜在的覆盖面。