Cardinal Matthew, Eisenbud David E, Armstrong David G
Clinical Department, Advanced BioHealing, La Jolla, California, USA.
Wound Repair Regen. 2009 Mar-Apr;17(2):173-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1524-475X.2009.00464.x.
Wound geometry measurements have long been associated with wound-healing outcomes but there is little published evidence to support this. We studied serial wound tracings of 338 venous leg ulcers (VLUs) that had been followed during a controlled, prospective, randomized pivotal trial of two topical wound treatments, to determine whether the relationship between wound surface area and wound perimeter planimetry measurements, as well as the qualitative assessment of wound shape, could be correlated to wound-healing outcomes. VLUs that transitioned to a more convex wound shape, and maintained a linear relationship between their wound margin size and wound surface area size, had faster healing rates and were more likely to completely heal by 12 weeks (odds ratio=4.84, p=0.001). VLUs that initially presented with isolated areas of epithelium within the wound margins, large concavities, or were segmented into multiple ulcers typically had a poorer linear correlation between their margins and their surface area. Only 18 out of 134 (13%) VLUs with a linear r(2)<0.80 eventually reached full wound closure, vs. 43% (102 of 270) of the remaining wounds with an r(2)> or =0.80 (Fisher's exact p<0.001). We believe our results show that the proportional relationship between one-dimensional perimeter and area measurements accurately correlates to the healing progress of the wound. Wounds that do not correlate to this linear relationship (concave geometries or multiple islands of healing) may be physiologically different than wounds that have good linear correlation, which we concluded through the analysis of wound acetate tracings.
伤口几何测量长期以来一直与伤口愈合结果相关,但几乎没有公开的证据支持这一点。我们研究了338例下肢静脉溃疡(VLU)的连续伤口描记图,这些伤口在两项局部伤口治疗的对照、前瞻性、随机关键试验中进行了跟踪,以确定伤口表面积与伤口周长平面测量之间的关系,以及伤口形状的定性评估是否与伤口愈合结果相关。转变为更凸形伤口形状并在伤口边缘大小和伤口表面积大小之间保持线性关系的VLU愈合速度更快,并且在12周时更有可能完全愈合(优势比=4.84,p=0.001)。最初在伤口边缘出现孤立上皮区域、大凹陷或被分割成多个溃疡的VLU,其边缘与表面积之间的线性相关性通常较差。在134例线性r(2)<0.80的VLU中,只有18例(13%)最终实现了伤口完全闭合,而其余r(2)>或=0.80的伤口中有43%(270例中的102例)实现了完全闭合(Fisher精确检验p<0.001)。我们相信我们的结果表明,一维周长和面积测量之间的比例关系与伤口的愈合进程准确相关。通过对伤口醋酸盐描记图的分析,我们得出结论,与这种线性关系不相关的伤口(凹形几何形状或多个愈合岛)在生理上可能与具有良好线性相关性的伤口不同。