Weber Martin A, Ashworth Michael T, Anthony Risdon R, Malone Marian, Sebire Neil J
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children and Institute of Child Health, University College London, London, UK.
Forensic Sci Int. 2009 May 30;187(1-3):51-7. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2009.02.016. Epub 2009 Mar 28.
Alveolar haemosiderin-laden macrophages (HLMs) in histological sections of the lung represent evidence of previous pulmonary haemorrhage and in infants may be associated with features of non-accidental injury (NAI). The aim of this study is to establish the frequency of alveolar HLMs detected at post-mortem in a large series of sudden unexpected infant deaths, and to determine their clinical significance with particular regard to a possible association with NAI. A search was performed of a database of 1516 anonymised paediatric autopsies to identify all infants (<1 year of age) that died suddenly and unexpectedly in whom HLMs were demonstrated on routine histological examination of lung sections using special iron (Perls') stains. Clinical details and other post-mortem findings were then reviewed. During the study period (1996-2005 inclusive), there were 601 sudden unexpected infant deaths. Of the 536 autopsies in whom histological data regarding HLMs were recorded and slides were available for review, 29 (5%) demonstrated alveolar HLMs in lung sections. In 9 (31%) infants there were additional features of NAI; in 11 (38%) infants, there were features in the clinical history and/or on pathological examination of natural disease sufficient to potentially explain the presence of HLMs, and 9 (31%) represented otherwise unexplained infant deaths with no significant clinical history or other abnormalities. HLMs were present in 9 of the 27 (33%) total infant deaths with other features indicative of NAI, compared to only 9 of the 242 (4%) unexplained infant deaths without any other features of NAI or other contributory pathology (difference 29.6%, 95% CI 14.6-48.6%, p<0.0001; positive likelihood ratio 9.0, 95% CI 3.9-19.8). This association remained even if cases with rib fractures were excluded. Alveolar HLMs may be identified in a significant minority of sudden infant deaths following routine histological examination of the lungs with special stains for iron pigment. In most, there will be features in the clinical history or findings at post-mortem to indicate underlying natural disease which may account for their presence. However, in the absence of such features, alveolar HLMs, whilst not diagnostic, are associated with a significantly increased risk for the detection of other features of NAI; the presence of otherwise unexplained alveolar HLMs at autopsy should therefore prompt a careful exclusion of inflicted injury.
肺组织学切片中的肺泡含铁血黄素巨噬细胞(HLMs)代表既往肺出血的证据,在婴儿中可能与非意外性损伤(NAI)的特征相关。本研究的目的是确定在大量婴儿猝死尸检中检测到的肺泡HLMs的频率,并确定其临床意义,尤其关注其与NAI的可能关联。对一个包含1516例匿名儿科尸检的数据库进行检索,以识别所有突然意外死亡的1岁以下婴儿,这些婴儿在使用特殊铁(Perls)染色对肺切片进行常规组织学检查时发现有HLMs。然后回顾临床细节和其他尸检结果。在研究期间(1996 - 2005年,含1996年和2005年),共有601例婴儿猝死。在记录了关于HLMs的组织学数据且有切片可供复查的536例尸检中,29例(5%)在肺切片中显示有肺泡HLMs。在9例(31%)婴儿中有NAI的其他特征;在11例(38%)婴儿中,临床病史和/或自然疾病的病理检查中有足以潜在解释HLMs存在的特征,9例(31%)代表其他无法解释的婴儿死亡,无明显临床病史或其他异常。在27例(33%)有其他提示NAI特征的婴儿死亡中,有9例存在HLMs,相比之下,在242例无NAI其他特征或其他相关病理表现的无法解释的婴儿死亡中,只有9例(4%)存在HLMs(差异29.6%,95%可信区间14.6 - 48.6%,p < 0.0001;阳性似然比9.0,95%可信区间3.9 - 19.8)。即使排除肋骨骨折的病例,这种关联仍然存在。在对肺进行常规组织学检查并用特殊染色检测铁色素后,在相当一部分婴儿猝死中可识别出肺泡HLMs。在大多数情况下,临床病史或尸检结果中会有特征表明潜在的自然疾病可解释其存在。然而,在没有这些特征的情况下,肺泡HLMs虽不能确诊,但与检测到NAI的其他特征的风险显著增加相关;因此,尸检中出现无法解释的肺泡HLMs应促使仔细排除受虐损伤。