Bruce Susan A, Scherer Yvonne K, Curran Cynthia C, Urschel Dorothy M, Erdley Scott, Ball Lisa S
University of Buffalo School of Nursing, Buffalo, New York, USA.
Nurs Educ Perspect. 2009 Jan-Feb;30(1):22-7.
Faculty at the University at Buffalo designed and implemented a mock cardiac arrest that involved joint participation by both undergraduate and graduate students. Various instruments were developed to evaluate the effectiveness of this teaching modality, including scales that measured pre- and postsimulation knowledge and confidence. Students were also asked to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the experience especially regarding teamwork during an emergency situation. Management of the arrest by the graduate students was evaluated using a scale that included competency criteria related to assessment, diagnosis, treatment, and resource management. Undergraduate students' performance was also evaluated. Using paired t-test statistics, postsimulation knowledge scores were significantly higher than presimulation scores (p = .000), while postsimulation confidence scores were not statistically significant (p = .177). Students at both levels reported high satisfaction with the experience and with the opportunity to participate in a simulated cardiac arrest as a member of the health team. The use of a computer-assisted human patient simulator involving different levels of nursing students appears to be an effective teaching method; more investigation into specific outcomes is needed.
布法罗大学的教员设计并实施了一次模拟心脏骤停活动,该活动有本科生和研究生共同参与。开发了各种工具来评估这种教学方式的有效性,包括测量模拟前后知识和信心的量表。还要求学生评估这次经历的优点和缺点,特别是在紧急情况下团队合作方面。使用一个包含与评估、诊断、治疗和资源管理相关的能力标准的量表来评估研究生对心脏骤停的处理情况。本科生的表现也进行了评估。使用配对t检验统计,模拟后的知识得分显著高于模拟前的得分(p = .000),而模拟后的信心得分无统计学意义(p = .177)。两个层次的学生都对这次经历以及作为医疗团队成员参与模拟心脏骤停的机会表示高度满意。使用涉及不同层次护理专业学生的计算机辅助人体患者模拟器似乎是一种有效的教学方法;需要对具体结果进行更多研究。