Srivastava Neeraj M, Awasthi Shally, Agarwal Girdhar G
Department of Pediatrics, Chattrapati Shahuji Maharaj Medical University, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2009 Apr 2;9:61. doi: 10.1186/1472-6963-9-61.
The state of Uttar Pradesh, India accounts for one-quarter of India's neonatal deaths and 8 percent of those worldwide. More than half (52%) of these deaths occur due to infections. In order to achieve Millennium Development Goal-4 of reducing child mortality by two-thirds by the year 2015, it is important to study factors which affect neonatal health. In Uttar Pradesh there is meager data for spending on health care in general and neonates in particular.
The study was conducted at an urban Reproductive and Child Health (RCH) center and a District hospital. Neonates were enrolled within 48 hours of birth and were followed-up once at 6 weeks +/- 15 days at the OPD of the respective hospitals or at home. This study assessed (1) distribution of neonatal illnesses and different health providers sought (2) distribution of out-of-pocket expenditures by type of illness and type of health provider sought (3) socio-economic distribution of neonatal illnesses, care-seeking behavior and out-of-pocket expenditures. Per-protocol analysis was performed.
Five hundred and ten neonates were enrolled and 481(94.4%) were followed-up. Parents of 50.3% (242/481) neonates reported at least one symptom of illness. Of these 22.3% (107/481) neonates had illnesses with at least one reported Integrated Management of Neonatal and Childhood Illnesses (IMNCI) danger sign. Among IMNCI illnesses, point prevalence of septicemia was 6.2% and pneumonia was 5.2% while among non-IMNCI illnesses point prevalence of upper respiratory infection was 9.5%, and diarrhea was 7%. Community based non-government dispensers (NGDs) were leading health providers (37.6%). Mean monthly income of families was 2804 Indian Rupees (INR) (range: 800 to 14000; n = 510), where US$ 1 = 42 INR. Mean out-of-pocket expenditure on neonatal illness was 547.5 INR (range: 1 to 15000; n = 202) and mean out-of-pocket expenditure for hospitalization was 4993 INR (range: 41 to 15000; n = 17). All hospitalizations were for IMNCI illnesses. Neonates from lower income strata were less likely to receive any medical care (p < 0.0001) and were also less likely to be seen by a Government provider (p = 0.03).
Since more than half of the neonates have morbidity and out-of-pocket expenditure on neonatal illnesses often exceeds the family income of the lower strata of the low income group in the community, there is a need to either introduce health insurance scheme or subsidize health care for them. Also, since NGDs, half of which could be unqualified are leading health providers, qualified medical care-seeking for sick newborns should be promoted in urban Lucknow.
印度北方邦的新生儿死亡数占印度新生儿死亡总数的四分之一,占全球的8%。其中超过半数(52%)的死亡是由感染导致的。为实现到2015年将儿童死亡率降低三分之二这一千年发展目标4,研究影响新生儿健康的因素非常重要。在北方邦,关于总体医疗保健支出尤其是新生儿医疗保健支出的数据非常匮乏。
该研究在一家城市生殖与儿童健康(RCH)中心和一家区级医院开展。新生儿在出生后48小时内登记入组,并在各自医院的门诊或家中于6周±15天进行一次随访。本研究评估了:(1)新生儿疾病分布以及寻求医疗服务的不同医疗服务提供者;(2)按疾病类型和寻求医疗服务提供者类型划分的自付费用分布;(3)新生儿疾病的社会经济分布、就医行为和自付费用。进行了符合方案分析。
共登记入组510名新生儿,481名(94.4%)完成随访。50.3%(242/481)的新生儿家长报告至少有一种疾病症状。其中,22.3%(107/481)的新生儿患有至少一种报告的新生儿和儿童疾病综合管理(IMNCI)危险体征的疾病。在IMNCI疾病中,败血症的时点患病率为6.2%,肺炎为5.2%;在非IMNCI疾病中,上呼吸道感染的时点患病率为9.5%,腹泻为7%。社区非政府诊所(NGD)是主要的医疗服务提供者(37.6%)。家庭月平均收入为2804印度卢比(INR)(范围:800至14000;n = 510),1美元 = 42印度卢比。新生儿疾病的平均自付费用为547.5印度卢比(范围:1至15000;n = 202),住院的平均自付费用为4993印度卢比(范围:41至15000;n = 17)。所有住院病例均为IMNCI疾病。低收入阶层的新生儿接受任何医疗护理的可能性较小(p < 0.0001),由政府医疗服务提供者诊治的可能性也较小(p = 0.03)。
由于超过半数的新生儿患病,且新生儿疾病的自付费用常常超过社区低收入群体中下层家庭的收入,因此有必要引入健康保险计划或为他们提供医疗补贴。此外,由于NGD是主要的医疗服务提供者,其中半数可能不合格,所以在勒克瑙市应促进患病新生儿寻求合格的医疗护理。