Mukerji Gaurav, Munasinghe Indumina, Raza Asif
Department of Urology, Ealing Hospital and Charing Cross Hospital, Southall, London, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2009 May;91(4):313-20. doi: 10.1308/003588409X391820. Epub 2009 Apr 2.
Peri-operative management of patients receiving platelet inhibitors, such as clopidogrel presents a dilemma to surgeons in every surgical specialty including urology. The risk of procedure-related bleeding while continuing clopidogrel needs to be weighed against the risk of thrombo-embolism after discontinuing it. The objective of the survey was to determine current UK practice regarding clopidogrel use/cessation in patients undergoing elective urological procedures.
A 10-part questionnaire relating to pre- and postoperative clopidogrel use was mailed to all UK urology consultants listed in the British Association of Urological Surgeons' directory.
A total of 570 questionnaires were sent and 297 (52%) were returned. The majority of respondents stop clopidogrel prior to TUR surgery (96.6%), major urological surgery (91.7%), TRUS biopsy (90.6%), ESWL (81.8%) and cystoscopy and biopsy (70.1%). The time clopidogrel was stopped pre-operatively and restarted postoperatively was very variable and dependent on local guidelines or urologist preference. Almost half (49.5%) of the respondents would stop clopidogrel irrespective of its indication and 40.7% never consulted a cardiologist/haematologist before stopping clopidogrel. Less than half (43.4%) had a protocol/guideline in place concerning stopping clopidogrel before surgery. Of respondents, 43% do not routinely prescribe bridging therapy after discontinuing clopidogrel. Over half (55%) reported bleeding complications in patients who continued their clopidogrel during urological procedures and 22 (7.4%) of respondents reported an adverse thrombo-embolic event after stopping clopidogrel. The vast majority of respondents (92.8%) felt evidence-based guidelines on clopidogrel use during the peri-operative period would be useful.
This survey has highlighted a significant variation in practice with regards to pre- and postoperative management of clopidogrel in patients undergoing urological procedures. The results of this survey highlight the need for evidence-based guidelines for the peri-operative management of patients on clopidogrel.
对于接受血小板抑制剂(如氯吡格雷)治疗的患者,围手术期管理给包括泌尿外科在内的各个外科专业的外科医生带来了难题。继续使用氯吡格雷时与手术相关的出血风险需要与停药后血栓栓塞的风险进行权衡。本次调查的目的是确定英国目前在接受择期泌尿外科手术的患者中使用/停用氯吡格雷的情况。
一份包含10个部分、与术前和术后氯吡格雷使用情况相关的问卷被邮寄给了英国泌尿外科医师协会名录中列出的所有英国泌尿外科顾问医生。
共发放了570份问卷,回收297份(52%)。大多数受访者在经尿道前列腺电切术(TUR)手术前(96.6%)、大型泌尿外科手术前(91.7%)、经直肠超声引导下前列腺穿刺活检(TRUS)前(90.6%)、体外冲击波碎石术(ESWL)前(81.8%)以及膀胱镜检查和活检前(70.1%)停用氯吡格雷。氯吡格雷术前停药及术后重新开始使用的时间差异很大,取决于当地指南或泌尿外科医生的偏好。几乎一半(49.5%)的受访者会不顾氯吡格雷的适应证而停药,40.7%的受访者在停用氯吡格雷前从未咨询过心脏病专家/血液科医生。不到一半(43.4%)的受访者有关于术前停用氯吡格雷的方案/指南。在受访者中,43%在停用氯吡格雷后不常规开具桥接治疗药物。超过一半(55%)的受访者报告在泌尿外科手术期间继续使用氯吡格雷的患者出现了出血并发症,22名(7.4%)受访者报告在停用氯吡格雷后出现了不良血栓栓塞事件。绝大多数受访者(92.8%)认为围手术期氯吡格雷使用的循证指南会很有用。
本次调查突出了在接受泌尿外科手术患者的氯吡格雷术前和术后管理方面存在显著的实践差异。本次调查结果强调了需要有针对服用氯吡格雷患者围手术期管理的循证指南。