Solomon Kerry D, Fernández de Castro Luis E, Sandoval Helga P, Biber Joseph M, Groat Brian, Neff Kristiana D, Ying Michelle S, French John W, Donnenfeld Eric D, Lindstrom Richard L
Magill Research Center for Vision Correction, Storm Eye Institute, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, South Carolina 29425, USA.
Ophthalmology. 2009 Apr;116(4):691-701. doi: 10.1016/j.ophtha.2008.12.037.
To analyze the patient reported outcome of satisfaction after LASIK surgery.
Systematic review.
Patient data from previously reported studies.
A literature search conducted for the years 1988 to 2008 that included pertinent LASIK surgery information from the review of 2915 retrieved citations. All abstracts from these citations were reviewed and 1581 were deemed to be relevant for review. Complete copies of each of these relevant (1581) articles were obtained, and after thorough analysis each was rated based on the strength of the study design and weight of evidence. A level I rating was assigned to properly conducted, well-designed, randomized clinical trials; a level II rating to well-designed cohort and case-control studies; and a level III rating to case series, case reports, and poorly designed prospective and retrospective studies. Level I and II rated, peer-reviewed articles were entered into a database, and level III articles were eliminated. A total of 309 articles were incorporated into this database, representing level I and level II well-controlled studies of primary LASIK surgery.
Patients' satisfaction rates and factors associated with dissatisfaction.
Nineteen of the 309 database articles (6.1%) reported on both patient quality of life and satisfaction and together encompassed a total of 2198 subjects. The procedures from these 19 articles took place between 1995 and 2003. The overall patient satisfaction rate after primary LASIK surgery was 95.4% (2097 of 2198 subjects; range of patient satisfaction for the 19 articles was 87.2%-100%). The patient satisfaction rate after myopic LASIK was 95.3% (1811 of 1901 patients), and after hyperopic LASIK was 96.3% (286 of 297 subjects).
Based on this review, worldwide, an average 95.4% of patients were satisfied with their outcome after LASIK surgery. With 16.3 million procedures performed worldwide, and more than a decade of clinical studies and technological innovation, LASIK surgery should be considered among the most successful elective procedures. LASIK surgery compares more favorably with other elective surgical procedures in terms of generally higher satisfaction rates.
分析患者报告的准分子激光原位角膜磨镶术(LASIK)术后满意度。
系统评价。
来自既往报道研究的患者数据。
检索1988年至2008年的文献,从2915条检索到的引文中筛选出包含相关LASIK手术信息的文献。对这些引文的所有摘要进行了审查,其中1581条被认为与综述相关。获取了这1581篇相关文章的完整副本,并在进行全面分析后,根据研究设计的强度和证据权重对每篇文章进行评分。设计合理、实施得当的随机临床试验被评为I级;设计良好的队列研究和病例对照研究被评为II级;病例系列、病例报告以及设计不佳的前瞻性和回顾性研究被评为III级。I级和II级且经过同行评审的文章被录入数据库,III级文章被剔除。共有309篇文章被纳入该数据库,代表了对原发性LASIK手术的I级和II级严格对照研究。
患者的满意度及与不满意相关的因素。
309篇数据库文章中有19篇(6.1%)报告了患者的生活质量和满意度,共纳入2198名受试者。这19篇文章中的手术时间在1995年至2003年之间。原发性LASIK手术后患者的总体满意度为95.4%(2198名受试者中的2097名;这19篇文章的患者满意度范围为87.2%-100%)。近视LASIK术后患者满意度为95.3%(1901名患者中的1811名),远视LASIK术后患者满意度为96.3%(297名受试者中的286名)。
基于本综述,在全球范围内,平均95.4%的患者对LASIK手术的结果感到满意。全球已实施了1630万例手术,经过十多年的临床研究和技术创新,LASIK手术应被视为最成功的择期手术之一。与其他择期手术相比,LASIK手术的总体满意度通常更高,具有更大优势。