Sanderson R O, Beata C, Flipo R-M, Genevois J-P, Macias C, Tacke S, Vezzoni A, Innes J F
Small Animal Teaching Hospital and Musculoskeletal Research Group, Faculty of Veterinary Science, University of Liverpool, Leahurst, Neston, Cheshire CH64 7TE.
Vet Rec. 2009 Apr 4;164(14):418-24. doi: 10.1136/vr.164.14.418.
This review assesses the evidence for the efficacy of therapies used in the management of osteoarthritis in dogs on the basis of papers published in peer-reviewed journals in English between 1985 and July 2007. Sixty-eight papers were identified and evaluated. They considered four alternative therapies, one use of functional food, two intra-articular agents, six nutraceutical agents, 21 pharmacological agents, two physical therapies, three surgical techniques and two combinations of weight control. There was a high level of comfort (strong evidence) for the efficacy of carprofen, firocoxib and meloxicam, and a moderate level of comfort for the efficacy of etodolac in modifying the signs of osteoarthritis. There was a moderate level of comfort for the efficacy of glycosaminoglycan polysulphate, licofelone, elk velvet antler and a functional food containing green-lipped mussel for the modification of the structures involved in the disease. There was weak or no evidence in support of the use of doxycycline, electrostimulated acupuncture, extracorporeal shockwave therapy, gold wire acupuncture, hyaluronan, pentosan polysulphate, P54FP (extract of turmeric), tiaprofenic acid or tibial plateau levelling osteotomy.
本综述基于1985年至2007年7月间发表在英文同行评审期刊上的论文,评估了用于治疗犬骨关节炎的疗法的疗效证据。共识别并评估了68篇论文。这些论文涉及四种替代疗法、一种功能性食品的应用、两种关节内用药、六种营养保健品、21种药物、两种物理疗法、三种手术技术以及两种体重控制组合。对于卡洛芬、非罗考昔和美洛昔康的疗效,有高度的可信度(强有力的证据);对于依托度酸改善骨关节炎症状的疗效,有中等程度的可信度。对于硫酸糖胺聚糖、利考昔芬、鹿茸以及一种含绿唇贻贝的功能性食品改善疾病相关结构的疗效,有中等程度的可信度。几乎没有证据支持使用强力霉素、电刺激针灸、体外冲击波疗法、金丝针灸、透明质酸、戊聚糖多硫酸盐、P54FP(姜黄提取物)、噻洛芬酸或胫骨平台水平截骨术。