Gomes Cristina M, Boesch Christophe
Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology, Leipzig, Germany.
PLoS One. 2009;4(4):e5116. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0005116. Epub 2009 Apr 8.
Humans and chimpanzees are unusual among primates in that they frequently perform group hunts of mammalian prey and share meat with conspecifics. Especially interesting are cases in which males give meat to unrelated females. The meat-for-sex hypothesis aims at explaining these cases by proposing that males and females exchange meat for sex, which would result in males increasing their mating success and females increasing their caloric intake without suffering the energetic costs and potential risk of injury related to hunting. Although chimpanzees have been shown to share meat extensively with females, there has not been much direct evidence in this species to support the meat-for-sex hypothesis. Here we show that female wild chimpanzees copulate more frequently with those males who, over a period of 22 months, share meat with them. We excluded other alternative hypotheses to exchanging meat for sex, by statistically controlling for rank of the male, age, rank and gregariousness of the female, association patterns of each male-female dyad and meat begging frequency of each female. Although males were more likely to share meat with estrous than anestrous females given their proportional representation in hunting parties, the relationship between mating success and sharing meat remained significant after excluding from the analysis sharing episodes with estrous females. These results strongly suggest that wild chimpanzees exchange meat for sex, and do so on a long-term basis. Similar studies on humans will determine if the direct nutritional benefits that women receive from hunters in foraging societies could also be driving the relationship between reproductive success and good hunting skills.
人类和黑猩猩在灵长类动物中较为特殊,它们经常集体捕猎哺乳动物猎物,并与同种个体分享肉类。特别有趣的是雄性给与非亲属雌性肉类的情况。“以肉换性”假说旨在通过提出雄性和雌性以肉换性来解释这些情况,这将导致雄性提高交配成功率,雌性增加热量摄入,同时又不会承受与捕猎相关的能量消耗和受伤风险。尽管已证明黑猩猩会与雌性广泛分享肉类,但在该物种中,尚未有太多直接证据支持“以肉换性”假说。在此我们表明,雌性野生黑猩猩与那些在22个月期间与它们分享肉类的雄性交配更为频繁。我们通过对雄性的等级、年龄、雌性的等级和群居性、每对雌雄组合的关联模式以及每个雌性的乞肉频率进行统计控制,排除了其他以肉换性的替代假说。尽管鉴于雄性在狩猎群体中的比例代表,它们更有可能与处于发情期而非非发情期的雌性分享肉类,但在分析中排除与发情期雌性的分享事件后,交配成功率与分享肉类之间的关系仍然显著。这些结果有力地表明,野生黑猩猩以肉换性,而且是长期如此。对人类进行的类似研究将确定,在觅食社会中,女性从猎手那里获得的直接营养益处是否也推动了生殖成功与良好狩猎技能之间的关系。