Cay Serkan, Cagirci Goksel, Maden Orhan, Balbay Yucel, Aydogdu Sinan
Department of Cardiology, Yuksek Ihtisas Heart-Education and Research Hospital, 06480, Ankara, Turkey.
Kardiol Pol. 2009 Mar;67(3):274-80.
A zoonotic infection caused by Brucella spp., brucellosis, is endemic in some areas of the world, like in our country. One of the most devastating conditions related to this infection is endocarditis, although it is rare. Unfortunately, adequate studies on the characteristics of Brucella endocarditis have not been performed. In addition, there was no consensus on optimal type and duration of medical and interventional therapies.
To answer the following questions: what are the clinical characteristics of Brucella endocarditis, which type of therapy should be performed, and can an alternative antibiotic regimen be applied?
Patients with the diagnosis of Brucella endocarditis were included in the study during a 6-year period. A total of 10 patients were interrogated for their signs, symptoms, drug use, and clinical conditions. In addition, baseline clinical and laboratory characteristics of the patients were evaluated.
All patients in the study were male with a mean age of 55.9 +/- 12.7 years. Hospitalisation and total follow-up periods were 52.6 +/- 11.2 and 80.6 +/- 29.0 days, respectively. The most frequently presenting symptom was fever (60%). Dyspnoea and fatigue were the other frequent symptoms in descending order. Valve pathology was present in 70% of the study population. The aortic valve was affected more than the mitral valve. Affected mitral valves had rheumatic disease whereas only 57% of the aortic valves had underlying pathology. Isolation of Brucella spp. was possible in 20% of the patients. Mortality rate was 30% in our study; 20% of the patients were on medical follow-up without disease progression and with clinical stability, 60% of patients were on a combination therapy with a tetracycline group, a rifampicin, and a third-generation cephalosporin. Patients who took this combination and underwent aortic valve replacement had good clinical results with a mortality rate of 20%. The 30% of patients were on a combination therapy with a tetracycline group, rifampicin, and an aminoglycoside group. Mortality rate with this combination was 33%, although the success rate was 67%.
Brucella endocarditis should be considered in the differential diagnosis in patients with vegetations on the cardiac valves, especially in endemic areas. Optimal therapy seems to be a combination of antibiotics and surgery, although medical therapy can be an alternative, especially in stable patients. Addition of a third-generation cephalosporin instead of aminoglycoside to the combination therapy is an alternative.
布鲁氏菌属引起的人畜共患感染——布鲁氏菌病,在世界上一些地区呈地方性流行,在我国亦是如此。与这种感染相关的最严重病症之一是心内膜炎,尽管较为罕见。遗憾的是,尚未对布鲁氏菌心内膜炎的特征进行充分研究。此外,对于药物治疗和介入治疗的最佳类型及疗程尚无共识。
回答以下问题:布鲁氏菌心内膜炎的临床特征是什么,应采用哪种治疗方式,以及是否可以应用替代抗生素方案?
在6年期间纳入诊断为布鲁氏菌心内膜炎的患者进行研究。总共对10例患者询问了其体征、症状、用药情况及临床状况。此外,对患者的基线临床和实验室特征进行了评估。
研究中的所有患者均为男性,平均年龄为55.9±12.7岁。住院时间和总随访时间分别为52.6±11.2天和80.6±29.0天。最常见的症状是发热(60%)。呼吸困难和乏力是按顺序排列的其他常见症状。70%的研究人群存在瓣膜病变。主动脉瓣受累多于二尖瓣。受累的二尖瓣有风湿性疾病,而只有57%的主动脉瓣有潜在病变。20%的患者能够分离出布鲁氏菌属。本研究中的死亡率为30%;20%的患者接受医学随访,病情无进展且临床稳定,60%的患者接受四环素类、利福平及第三代头孢菌素联合治疗。接受这种联合治疗并接受主动脉瓣置换的患者临床效果良好,死亡率为20%。30%的患者接受四环素类、利福平及氨基糖苷类联合治疗。尽管成功率为67%,但这种联合治疗的死亡率为33%。
对于心脏瓣膜有赘生物的患者,尤其是在地方性流行地区,鉴别诊断时应考虑布鲁氏菌心内膜炎。最佳治疗似乎是抗生素与手术联合,不过药物治疗也可作为一种选择,特别是对于病情稳定的患者。联合治疗中添加第三代头孢菌素而非氨基糖苷类是一种替代方案。