Quandt Sara A, Verhoef Marja J, Arcury Thomas A, Lewith George T, Steinsbekk Aslak, Kristoffersen Agnete E, Wahner-Roedler Dietlind L, Fønnebø Vinjar
Department of Epidemiology and Prevention, Division of Public Health Sciences, Wake Forest University School of Medicine , Winston-Salem, NC 27157-1063, USA.
J Altern Complement Med. 2009 Apr;15(4):331-9. doi: 10.1089/acm.2008.0521.
Existing studies on the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) have produced diverse results regarding the types and prevalence of CAM use due, in part, to variations in the measurement of CAM modalities. A questionnaire that can be adapted for use in a variety of populations will improve CAM utilization measurement. The purposes of this article are to (1) articulate the need for such a common questionnaire; (2) describe the process of questionnaire development; (3) present a model questionnaire with core questions; and (4) suggest standard techniques for adapting the questionnaire to different languages and populations.
An international workshop sponsored by the National Research Center in Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NAFKAM) of the University of Tromsø, Norway, brought CAM researchers and practitioners together to design an international CAM questionnaire (I-CAM-Q). Existing questionnaires were critiqued, and working groups drafted content for a new questionnaire. A smaller working group completed, tested, and revised this self-administered questionnaire.
The questionnaire that was developed contains four sections concerned with visits to health care providers, complementary treatments received from physicians, use of herbal medicine and dietary supplements, and self-help practices. A priori-specified practitioners, therapies, supplements, and practices are included, as well as places for researcher-specified and respondent-specified additions. Core questions are designed to elicit frequency of use, purpose (treatment of acute or chronic conditions, and health maintenance), and satisfaction. A penultimate version underwent pretesting with "think-aloud" techniques to identify problems related to meaning and format. The final questionnaire is presented, with suggestions for testing and translating.
Once validated in English and non-English speaking populations, the I-CAM-Q will provide an opportunity for researchers to gather comparable data in studies conducted in different populations. Such data will increase knowledge about the epidemiology of CAM use and provide the foundation for evidence-based comparisons at an international level.
现有关于补充和替代医学(CAM)使用情况的研究,在CAM使用的类型和患病率方面得出了不同的结果,部分原因在于CAM模式测量方法的差异。一份可适用于各种人群的问卷将改善对CAM利用情况的测量。本文的目的是:(1)阐明对这样一份通用问卷的需求;(2)描述问卷开发过程;(3)呈现一份带有核心问题的问卷模板;(4)提出将问卷改编以适用于不同语言和人群的标准技术。
由挪威特罗姆瑟大学国家补充和替代医学研究中心(NAFKAM)主办的一次国际研讨会,召集了CAM研究人员和从业者共同设计一份国际CAM问卷(I-CAM-Q)。对现有的问卷进行了评估,各工作组起草了新问卷的内容。一个规模较小的工作组完成、测试并修订了这份自填式问卷。
所开发的问卷包含四个部分,涉及就医情况、从医生处接受的补充治疗、草药和膳食补充剂的使用以及自助疗法。问卷纳入了预先指定的从业者、疗法、补充剂和疗法,同时也留出了空间供研究人员指定和受访者自行填写补充内容。核心问题旨在引出使用频率、目的(治疗急性或慢性疾病以及健康维护)和满意度。倒数第二版问卷通过“边想边说”技术进行了预测试,以识别与含义和格式相关的问题。文中呈现了最终问卷,并给出了测试和翻译建议。
一旦在英语和非英语人群中得到验证,I-CAM-Q将为研究人员提供机会,在针对不同人群开展的研究中收集可比数据。这些数据将增加对CAM使用流行病学的了解,并为国际层面基于证据的比较提供基础。