2nd Department of Gastroenterology, Evangelismos General Hospital, Athens, Greece.
Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2009 Aug;21(8):866-71. doi: 10.1097/MEG.0b013e32831af1ec.
The aim of this study was to prospectively compare the diagnostic yield of wireless capsule endoscopy (WCE) and enteroclysis in the detection of Crohn's disease (CD) of the small bowel.
Twenty-nine patients with known CD (group 1) suspected to have more extensive small-bowel involvement and 26 patients, who were suspected to suffer from CD but did not have an earlier history of it (group 2) were prospectively evaluated with enteroclysis and WCE. Each examiner was blinded to the results of other investigations.
Enteroclysis was unsuccessful in two patients from group 1 8 and six patients from group 2, respectively. In group 1, abnormal findings consistent with CD were detected in 20 patients by using WCE and in 11 patients by using enteroclysis, out of the total 27, at per-protocol analysis (74.1 vs. 40.7%, P<0.05). Of the 11 patients who had ileal CD on enteroclysis, three had more extensive small-bowel disease, which was detected only by WCE. In group 2, WCE showed findings consistent with CD in 13 of 20 patients, in contrast with enteroclysis, which was positive for CD in only six of 20 patients (65 vs. 30%, P<0.05). Three more patients had findings compatible with CD on WCE, but they failed their enteroclysis. Overall, a new diagnosis of CD was made in 16 patients.
WCE has a higher diagnostic yield than enteroclysis in the detection of CD of the small bowel, both in patients with known and newly suspected CD.
本研究旨在前瞻性比较无线胶囊内镜(WCE)和小肠灌肠造影在克罗恩病(CD)小肠检测中的诊断效能。
29 例已知 CD(组 1)且疑似小肠受累更广泛的患者和 26 例疑似 CD 但无既往病史的患者(组 2),分别行小肠灌肠造影和 WCE 检查。每位检查者均对其他检查结果不知情。
组 1 中有 2 例患者和组 2 中有 6 例患者的小肠灌肠造影不成功。在组 1 中,27 例患者中,20 例患者通过 WCE 发现与 CD 一致的异常表现,11 例患者通过小肠灌肠造影发现异常表现,在方案分析中,WCE 的检出率为 74.1%,小肠灌肠造影为 40.7%(P<0.05)。在 11 例经小肠灌肠造影诊断为回肠 CD 的患者中,有 3 例存在更广泛的小肠病变,这仅通过 WCE 发现。在组 2 中,20 例患者中,WCE 发现 13 例与 CD 一致的表现,而小肠灌肠造影在 20 例患者中仅发现 6 例 CD 阳性(65%对 30%,P<0.05)。在 WCE 上又有 3 例患者发现与 CD 相符的表现,但小肠灌肠造影未能发现。总体而言,16 例患者新诊断为 CD。
WCE 在检测已知和新疑似 CD 患者的小肠 CD 方面,其诊断效能优于小肠灌肠造影。