Crawcour Stephen, Bowers Andrew, Harkrider Ashley, Saltuklaroglu Tim
Department of Audiology and Speech Language Pathology, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN 37996-0740, USA.
Neuropsychologia. 2009 Oct;47(12):2558-63. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2009.05.001. Epub 2009 May 13.
Motor involvement in speech perception has been recently studied using a variety of techniques. In the current study, EEG measurements from Cz, C3 and C4 electrodes were used to examine the relative power of the mu rhythm (i.e., 8-13 Hz) in response to various audio-visual speech and non-speech stimuli, as suppression of these rhythms is considered an index of 'mirror neuron' (i.e., motor) activity. Fourteen adult native English speaking females watched and listened to nine audio-video stimuli clips assembled from three different auditory stimuli (speech, noise, and pure tone) combined with three different video stimuli (speech, noise, and kaleidoscope-made from scrambling an image from the visual speech). Relative to the noise-noise (baseline condition), all visual speech conditions resulted in significant levels of suppression, a finding that is consistent with previous reports of mirror activity to visual speech and mu suppression to 'biological' stimuli. None of the non-speech conditions or conditions in which speech was presented via audition only resulted in any significant suppression of the mu rhythm in this population. Thus, visual speech perception appears to be more closely associated with motor activity than acoustic speech perception. It is postulated that in this study, the processing demands incurred by the task were insufficient for inducing significant mu suppression via acoustic speech only. The findings are discussed in theoretical contexts of speech perception and the mirror system. We suggest that this technique may offer a cost-efficient, non-invasive technique for measuring motor activity during speech perception.
最近,人们使用各种技术对言语感知中的运动参与进行了研究。在本研究中,使用来自Cz、C3和C4电极的脑电图测量来检查在各种视听言语和非言语刺激下μ节律(即8-13赫兹)的相对功率,因为这些节律的抑制被认为是“镜像神经元”(即运动)活动的一个指标。14名以英语为母语的成年女性观看并聆听了9个视听刺激片段,这些片段由三种不同的听觉刺激(言语、噪声和纯音)与三种不同的视觉刺激(言语、噪声和由视觉言语中的图像打乱后制成的万花筒)组合而成。相对于噪声-噪声(基线条件),所有视觉言语条件都导致了显著水平的抑制,这一发现与之前关于对视觉言语的镜像活动和对“生物”刺激的μ抑制的报告一致。在这一人群中,没有一种非言语条件或仅通过听觉呈现言语的条件导致μ节律有任何显著抑制。因此,视觉言语感知似乎比听觉言语感知与运动活动的联系更紧密。据推测,在本研究中,任务所带来的处理需求不足以仅通过听觉言语诱导显著的μ抑制。我们在言语感知和镜像系统的理论背景下讨论了这些发现。我们认为,这种技术可能为测量言语感知过程中的运动活动提供一种经济高效的非侵入性技术。