Quittner Alexandra L, Modi Avani C, Wainwright Claire, Otto Kelly, Kirihara Jean, Montgomery A Bruce
University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL.
Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center and the University of Cincinnati, Cincinnati, OH.
Chest. 2009 Jun;135(6):1610-1618. doi: 10.1378/chest.08-1190. Epub 2009 May 15.
The Cystic Fibrosis Questionnaire-Revised (CFQ-R) is a validated patient-reported outcome (PRO) containing both generic scales and scales specific to cystic fibrosis (CF). The minimal clinically important difference (MCID) score for a PRO corresponds to the smallest clinically relevant change a patient can detect. MCID scores for the CFQ-R respiratory symptom (CFQ-R-Respiratory) scale were determined using data from two 28 day, open-label, tobramycin inhalation solution (TIS) studies in patients with CF and chronic Pseudomonas aeruginosa airway infection. At study enrollment, patients in the study 1-exacerbation had symptoms indicative of pulmonary exacerbation (n = 84; < 14 years of age, 31 patients; > or = 14 years of age, 53 patients); patients in study 2-stable had stable respiratory symptoms (n = 140; < 14 years of age, 14 patients; > or = 14 years, 126 patients).
The anchor-based method utilized a global rating-of-change questionnaire (GRCQ) that assessed patients' perceptions of change in their respiratory symptoms after TIS treatment. The mean change from baseline CFQ-R-Respiratory scores were mapped onto the GRCQ to estimate the MCID. The two distribution-based methods were as follows: (1) 0.5 SD of mean change in CFQ-R-Respiratory scores (baseline to end of TIS treatment); and (2) 1 SEM for baseline CFQ-R-Respiratory scores. Triangulation of these three estimates defined the MCIDs.
MCID scores were larger for patients in study 1-exacerbation (8.5 points) than for those in study 2-stable (4.0 points), likely reflecting differences in patient disease status (exacerbation/stable) between these studies.
Patient benefit from new and current CF therapies can be evaluated using changes in CFQ-R-Respiratory scores. Using the MCID provides a systematic way to interpret these changes, and facilitates the identification of CF treatments that improve both symptoms and physiologic variables, potentially leading to better treatment adherence and clinical outcomes. Trial registration (study 1-exacerbation): Australian-New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry Identifier: ACTRN 12605000602628 Trial registration (study 2-stable): ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT00104520.
囊性纤维化问卷修订版(CFQ-R)是一种经过验证的患者报告结局(PRO),包含通用量表和特定于囊性纤维化(CF)的量表。PRO的最小临床重要差异(MCID)分数对应于患者能够检测到的最小临床相关变化。CFQ-R呼吸症状(CFQ-R-Respiratory)量表的MCID分数是使用两项为期28天的开放标签妥布霉素吸入溶液(TIS)研究的数据确定的,这两项研究针对患有CF和慢性铜绿假单胞菌气道感染的患者。在研究入组时,研究1-加重组的患者有肺部加重的症状(n = 84;年龄<14岁,31例患者;年龄≥14岁,53例患者);研究2-稳定组的患者有稳定的呼吸症状(n = 140;年龄<14岁,14例患者;年龄≥14岁,126例患者)。
基于锚定的方法使用了一份整体变化评分问卷(GRCQ),该问卷评估了患者对TIS治疗后呼吸症状变化的感知。将CFQ-R-Respiratory评分从基线的平均变化映射到GRCQ上,以估计MCID。两种基于分布的方法如下:(1)CFQ-R-Respiratory评分(从基线到TIS治疗结束)平均变化的0.5个标准差;(2)CFQ-R-Respiratory评分基线的1个标准误。对这三个估计值进行三角测量确定了MCID。
研究1-加重组患者的MCID分数(8.5分)高于研究2-稳定组患者(4.0分),这可能反映了这些研究中患者疾病状态(加重/稳定)的差异。
可以使用CFQ-R-Respiratory评分的变化来评估患者从新的和现有的CF治疗中获得的益处。使用MCID提供了一种系统的方法来解释这些变化,并有助于识别既能改善症状又能改善生理变量的CF治疗方法,这可能会提高治疗依从性和临床结局。试验注册(研究1-加重组):澳大利亚-新西兰临床试验注册标识符:ACTRN 12605000602628 试验注册(研究2-稳定组):ClinicalTrials.gov标识符:NCT00104520。