Zhao Ying, Huang Yi-Na, Shi Lv, Chen Lin
Auditory Research Laboratory, School of Life Sciences, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230027, China.
Neurosci Bull. 2009 Jun;25(3):101-8. doi: 10.1007/s12264-009-0311-y.
The macula lagena in birds is located at the apical end of the cochlea and contains many tiny otoliths. The macula lagena is innervated and has neural projections to the brainstem, but its physiological function is still unclear. It remains disputable that it is because otoliths in the lagena are rich in elements Fe and Zn that birds can obtain geomagnetic information for homing. To clarify this issue, we carried out a study to determine whether or not otoliths in the lagena of homing pigeons are richer in magnetic elements than those in the saccule and the utricle.
The contents of ferromagnetic elements (Fe, Co, Ni) and other metal elements in lagenal otoliths of adult homing pigeons were precisely analyzed with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) of high sensitivity, and then they were compared with those in saccular and utricular otoliths (all the contents were normalized to Ca).
In adult homing pigeons, the contents of ferromagnetic elements (Fe, Co, Ni) in lagenal otoliths were less than 0.7% (normalized to Ca element) and were the same order in magnitude as those in saccular and utricular otoliths. The content of Fe in lagenal otoliths was not significantly different from that in utricular otoliths and was even lower than that in saccular otoliths. The content of Co in lagenal otoliths was lower than that in saccular otoliths and higher than that in utricular otoliths. The content of Ni in lagenal otoliths was not significantly different from that in saccular otoliths and was higher than that in utricular otoliths. The contents of other metal elements Na, Mg, K, Al, Mn and Pb in lagenal otoliths were not significantly different from those in utricular and saccular otoliths. The contents of metal elements Zn, Ba and Cu in lagenal otoliths were lower than those in saccular otoliths.
The contents of magnetic elements in lagenal otoliths of homing pigeons are not much higher than those in utricular and saccular otoliths, which does not support the hypothesis that birds depend on high contents of Fe and Zn in lagenal otoliths for sensation of geomagnetic information. Similarities in morphology, element ingredient and element content between lagenal otoliths and utricular otoliths suggest that the two types of otolithic organs may play similar roles in sensing gravitational and acceleration signals.
鸟类的瓶状囊斑位于耳蜗顶端,含有许多微小的耳石。瓶状囊斑有神经支配并向脑干发出神经投射,但其生理功能仍不清楚。关于鸟类能够通过瓶状囊耳石中富含铁和锌元素来获取地磁信息以进行归巢这一说法仍存在争议。为阐明这一问题,我们开展了一项研究,以确定归巢鸽瓶状囊中的耳石在磁性元素方面是否比球囊和椭圆囊中的耳石更丰富。
采用高灵敏度电感耦合等离子体质谱法(ICP-MS)精确分析成年归巢鸽瓶状囊耳石中铁磁元素(铁、钴、镍)和其他金属元素的含量,然后将其与球囊和椭圆囊耳石中的含量进行比较(所有含量均以钙为标准进行归一化)。
在成年归巢鸽中,瓶状囊耳石中铁磁元素(铁、钴、镍)的含量低于0.7%(以钙元素为标准进行归一化),与球囊和椭圆囊耳石中的含量处于同一数量级。瓶状囊耳石中的铁含量与椭圆囊耳石中的铁含量无显著差异,甚至低于球囊耳石中的铁含量。瓶状囊耳石中的钴含量低于球囊耳石中的钴含量,高于椭圆囊耳石中的钴含量。瓶状囊耳石中的镍含量与球囊耳石中的镍含量无显著差异,高于椭圆囊耳石中的镍含量。瓶状囊耳石中其他金属元素钠、镁、钾、铝、锰和铅的含量与椭圆囊和球囊耳石中的含量无显著差异。瓶状囊耳石中金属元素锌、钡和铜的含量低于球囊耳石中的含量。
归巢鸽瓶状囊耳石中的磁性元素含量并不比椭圆囊和球囊耳石中的含量高很多,这并不支持鸟类依靠瓶状囊耳石中高含量的铁和锌来感知地磁信息这一假说。瓶状囊耳石与椭圆囊耳石在形态、元素成分和元素含量上的相似性表明,这两种耳石器官在感知重力和加速度信号方面可能发挥相似的作用。