LoboPrabhu Sheila M, Molinari Victor A, Hamilton Joseph D, Lomax James W
Mental Health Care Line and MIRECC, Michael E. DeBakey Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Houston, TX 77030, USA.
Am J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2009 Jun;17(6):445-54. doi: 10.1097/JGP.0b013e31819e2d7e.
There are many important unanswered issues regarding the occurrence of cognitive impairment in physicians, such as detection of deficits, remediation efforts, policy implications for safe medical practice, and the need to safeguard quality patient care. The authors review existing literature on these complex issues and derive heuristic formulations regarding how to help manage the professional needs of the aging physician with dementia. To ensure safe standards of medical care while also protecting the needs of physicians and their families, state regulatory or licensing agencies in collaboration with state medical associations and academic medical centers should generate evaluation guidelines to assure continued high levels of functioning. The authors also raise the question of whether age should be considered as a risk factor that merits special screening for adequate functioning. Either age-related screening for cognitive impairment should be initiated or rigorous evaluation after lapses in standard of care should be the norm regardless of age. Ultimately, competence rather than mandatory retirement due to age per se should be the deciding factor regarding whether physicians should be able to continue their practice. Finally, the authors issue a call for an expert consensus panel to convene to make recommendations concerning aging physicians with cognitive impairment who are at risk for medical errors.
关于医生认知障碍的发生,存在许多重要的未解决问题,例如缺陷的检测、补救措施、安全医疗实践的政策影响以及保障优质患者护理的必要性。作者回顾了关于这些复杂问题的现有文献,并得出了关于如何帮助管理患有痴呆症的老年医生的专业需求的启发式表述。为了确保医疗护理的安全标准,同时也保护医生及其家人的需求,州监管或许可机构应与州医学协会和学术医疗中心合作,制定评估指南,以确保持续的高水平功能。作者还提出了一个问题,即年龄是否应被视为一个需要进行特殊筛查以确保适当功能的风险因素。要么应启动与年龄相关的认知障碍筛查,要么在护理标准出现失误后进行严格评估应成为常态,无论年龄大小。最终,决定医生是否能够继续执业的应该是能力,而不是因年龄本身而强制退休。最后,作者呼吁召集一个专家共识小组,就有医疗失误风险的患有认知障碍的老年医生提出建议。