Department of Neurology and Clinical Neurophysiology, Rudolf Magnus Institute of Neuroscience, University Medical Centre Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Brain. 2009 Nov;132(Pt 11):3060-71. doi: 10.1093/brain/awp137. Epub 2009 Jun 4.
Magnetoencephalography (MEG) is considered a useful tool for planning electrode placement for chronic intracranial subdural electrocorticography (ECoG) in candidates for epilepsy surgery or even as a substitute for ECoG. MEG recordings are usually interictal and therefore, at best, reflect the interictal ECoG. To estimate the clinical value of MEG, it is important to know how well interictal MEG reflects interictal activity in the ECoG. From 1998 to 2008, 38 candidates for ECoG underwent a 151-channel MEG recording and 3D magnetic resonance imaging as a part of their presurgical evaluation. Interictal MEG spikes were identified, clustered, averaged and modelled using the multiple signal classification algorithm and co-registered to magnetic resonance imaging. ECoG was continuously recorded with electrode grids and strips for approximately 1 week. In a representative sample of awake interictal ECoG, interictal spikes were identified and averaged. The different spikes were characterized and quantified using a combined amplitude and synchronous surface-area measure. The ECoG spikes were ranked according to this measure and plotted on the magnetic resonance imaging surface rendering. Interictal spikes in MEG and ECoG were allocated to a predefined anatomical brain region and an association analysis was performed. All interictal MEG spikes were associated with an interictal ECoG spike. Overall, 56% of all interictal ECoG spikes had an interictal MEG counterpart. The association between the two was >or=90% in the interhemispheric and frontal orbital region, approximately 75% in the superior frontal, central and lateral temporal regions, but only approximately 25% in the mesial temporal region. MEG is a reliable indicator of the presence of interictal ECoG spikes and can be used to plan intracranial electrode placements. However, a substantial number of interictal ECoG spikes are not detected by MEG, and therefore MEG cannot be considered a substitute for ECoG.
脑磁图(MEG)被认为是一种有用的工具,可用于规划癫痫手术候选者的慢性颅内硬脑膜下脑电描记术(ECoG)的电极放置,甚至可以替代 ECoG。MEG 记录通常是发作间期的,因此,充其量只能反映发作间期的 ECoG。为了评估 MEG 的临床价值,了解发作间期 MEG 如何反映 ECoG 中的发作间期活动非常重要。1998 年至 2008 年,38 名 ECoG 候选者接受了 151 通道 MEG 记录和 3D 磁共振成像作为其术前评估的一部分。使用多信号分类算法对发作间期 MEG 棘波进行识别、聚类、平均和建模,并与磁共振成像配准。ECoG 电极网格和条带持续记录约 1 周。在代表清醒发作间期 ECoG 的样本中,识别并平均发作间期棘波。使用组合幅度和同步表面积测量来对不同的棘波进行特征描述和量化。根据该测量标准对 ECoG 棘波进行排序,并绘制在磁共振成像表面渲染图上。MEG 和 ECoG 中的发作间期棘波被分配到预定义的解剖学脑区,并进行关联分析。所有发作间期 MEG 棘波都与发作间期 ECoG 棘波相关。总体而言,所有发作间期 ECoG 棘波中有 56%具有发作间期 MEG 对应物。在大脑半球间和额眶区,两者之间的关联>或=90%,在额上、中央和外侧颞区约为 75%,但在中颞区仅约为 25%。MEG 是发作间期 ECoG 棘波存在的可靠指标,可用于规划颅内电极放置。然而,大量的发作间期 ECoG 棘波无法被 MEG 检测到,因此 MEG 不能被视为 ECoG 的替代品。