Crumlish Colleen M, Yialamas Maria A, McMahon Graham T
Department of Medicine, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.
J Hosp Med. 2009 May;4(5):304-7. doi: 10.1002/jhm.540.
Medical educators have raised serious concerns about the decline in bedside teaching and the effect of this decline on trainee skills. We investigated the fraction of time hospitalist attending physicians spend at the bedside during teaching rounds and how often physical examination skills are demonstrated.
In a prospective, observational study, the authors investigated the rounding behavior of members of Brigham and Women's Hospitalist Service. For 5 weeks from December 2007 to January 2008, interns and residents rotating on the hospitalist service reported in a daily e-mail (1) total time spent with their attending during attending rounds, (2) time spent inside patient rooms during attending rounds, and (3) whether or not a physical examination finding or technique was demonstrated by their hospitalist attending.
A total of 61 observations were reported (66% response). Hospitalists spent an average of 101 minutes on teaching rounds and an average of 17 minutes inside patient rooms or 17% of their teaching time at the bedside. Bedside teaching occurred during 61% of teaching sessions and physical examination teaching occurred during 38% of teaching sessions. Rounds that included time spent at the bedside were longer on average than rounds that did not include time spent at the bedside (122 vs. 69 minutes, P < 0.001).
Bedside teaching makes up approximately 17% of the time that hospitalists at this medical center spend on teaching rounds. Physical examination teaching has become infrequent. Research to clarify optimal strategies to improve bedside teaching and its value in patient care is needed.
医学教育工作者对床边教学的减少及其对实习生技能的影响表示严重关切。我们调查了住院医师在教学查房时在床边花费的时间比例以及体格检查技能的演示频率。
在一项前瞻性观察研究中,作者调查了布莱根妇女医院住院医师团队成员的查房行为。在2007年12月至2008年1月的5周时间里,在住院医师团队轮转的实习生和住院医师通过每日电子邮件报告:(1)在主治医师查房期间与主治医师共度的总时间;(2)在主治医师查房期间在病房内花费的时间;(3)他们的住院医师主治医师是否演示了体格检查结果或技术。
共报告了61次观察结果(回复率66%)。住院医师平均花费101分钟进行教学查房,平均在病房内花费17分钟,即他们在床边教学时间的17%。61%的教学时段进行了床边教学,38%的教学时段进行了体格检查教学。包括在床边花费时间的查房平均比不包括在床边花费时间的查房更长(122分钟对69分钟,P<0.001)。
在该医疗中心,床边教学约占住院医师教学查房时间的17%。体格检查教学已变得不常见。需要开展研究以明确改善床边教学及其在患者护理中的价值的最佳策略。