Olliaro Piero, Darley Sarah, Laxminarayan Ramanan, Sundar Shyam
UNICEF/UNDP/WB/WHO Special Programme for Research and Training in Tropical Diseases, Geneva, Switzerland.
Trop Med Int Health. 2009 Aug;14(8):918-25. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-3156.2009.02306.x. Epub 2009 Jun 28.
To assess the cost-effectiveness of current monotherapies and prospective combinations for treating visceral leishmaniasis (VL) in Bihar, India in terms of years of life lost (YLL) averted as well as deaths averted.
We employed two methods to estimate the number of avertable deaths in our analysis: one using estimated mortality, the other using direct incidence estimates for VL. Costs of care are based on an average private hospital in Bihar, and data on drug costs were obtained both locally and from the World Health Organization.
The cost of monotherapies per averted YLL ranged from US$2 for paromomycin in an outpatient setting to US$20-22 for AmBisome at 20 mg/kg. The corresponding costs per death averted ranged from US$53-54 to US$523-527. Combinations ranged US$5-8 per YLL averted and US$124-213 per death averted.
The available treatments for VL are cost-effective, and our mortality and incidence-based methods produce consistent estimates. The combinations considered here were more cost-effective than most monotherapies. Having multiple treatment options and combining drugs are also likely to reduce drug pressure and prolong the drugs' life-span of effective use.
从避免的生命年损失(YLL)以及避免的死亡人数方面,评估印度比哈尔邦目前治疗内脏利什曼病(VL)的单一疗法和未来联合疗法的成本效益。
我们在分析中采用了两种方法来估计可避免的死亡人数:一种使用估计的死亡率,另一种使用VL的直接发病率估计值。护理成本基于比哈尔邦的一家普通私立医院,药品成本数据来自当地和世界卫生组织。
每避免一个YLL的单一疗法成本,从门诊使用巴龙霉素时的2美元到使用20mg/kg的两性霉素B脂质体时的20 - 22美元不等。每避免一例死亡的相应成本,从53 - 54美元到523 - 527美元不等。联合疗法每避免一个YLL的成本为5 - 8美元,每避免一例死亡的成本为124 - 213美元。
现有的VL治疗方法具有成本效益,我们基于死亡率和发病率的方法得出了一致的估计结果。这里考虑的联合疗法比大多数单一疗法更具成本效益。拥有多种治疗选择和联合用药也可能会减轻药物压力并延长药物的有效使用期限。