Iseli T A, Karnell L H, Graham S M, Funk G F, Buatti J M, Gupta A K, Robinson R A, Hoffman H T
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics, Iowa City, Iowa 52242, USA.
J Laryngol Otol. 2009 Oct;123(10):1137-44. doi: 10.1017/S0022215109990338. Epub 2009 Jul 2.
This study retrospectively reviewed 183 cases of adenoid cystic carcinoma treated over 40 years. The local recurrence free survival rate was 68.2 per cent at five years and 40.8 per cent at 10 years. At 10 years, local recurrence free survival was significantly worse following radiotherapy alone (0 per cent), compared with surgery alone (41.8 per cent, p = 0.004) or combined with post-operative radiotherapy (43.5 per cent, p = 0.001). Neither tumour stage three or four, perineural invasion, solid subtype nor involved margins predicted local recurrence. Treatment with radiotherapy alone resulted in worse survival than surgery alone (p = 0.002) or combined with post-operative radiotherapy (p = 0.001). Survival rates following local recurrence (n = 34) were higher following surgery (p = 0.006) but not significantly improved following radiotherapy (p = 0.139). Chemotherapy for distant metastases did not prolong survival (p = 0.747) but did result in improved eating and aesthetics scores, while decreasing overall physical health. These results indicate that surgery is preferable for primary and recurrent adenoid cystic carcinoma of the head and neck. The incidence of local recurrence following surgery and postoperative radiotherapy was similar to surgery alone cases although the latter had less adverse prognostic features. Contemporary chemotherapy may benefit quality of life but not survival in patients with distant metastases due to adenoid cystic carcinoma of the head and neck.
本研究回顾性分析了40多年来治疗的183例腺样囊性癌病例。5年局部无复发生存率为68.2%,10年为40.8%。10年时,单纯放疗后的局部无复发生存情况明显较差(0%),而单纯手术(41.8%,p = 0.004)或联合术后放疗(43.5%,p = 0.001)则较好。肿瘤分期为三或四期、神经周围侵犯、实性亚型或切缘受累均不能预测局部复发。单纯放疗的生存率低于单纯手术(p = 0.002)或联合术后放疗(p = 0.001)。局部复发(n = 34)后,手术组的生存率较高(p = 0.006),但放疗组无显著改善(p = 0.139)。远处转移的化疗并不能延长生存期(p = 0.747),但确实能改善饮食和美观评分,同时降低总体身体健康状况。这些结果表明,手术是治疗头颈部原发性和复发性腺样囊性癌的首选方法。手术联合术后放疗后的局部复发率与单纯手术病例相似,尽管后者不良预后特征较少。当代化疗可能有益于头颈部腺样囊性癌远处转移患者的生活质量,但对生存期无影响。