Malik Marek, Hnatkova Katerina, Schmidt Anna, Smetana Peter
St. Paul's Cardiac Electrophysiology, London, England.
Ann Noninvasive Electrocardiol. 2009 Jul;14(3):242-50. doi: 10.1111/j.1542-474X.2009.00304.x.
The so-called thorough QT/QTc (TQT) studies required for every new pharmaceutical compound are negative if upper single-sided 95% confidence interval (CI) of placebo and baseline corrected QTc prolongation is <10 ms. This tight requirement has many methodological implications. If the investigated drug has a fast action and ECGs cannot be obtained at stable heart rates, QT/RR hysteresis correction is needed.
This was used in a TQT study of gadobutrol. The TQT study was a randomized double-blind five-times crossover study of three doses of gadobutrol (0.1, 0.3, and 0.5 mmol/kg) that was placebo and positive effect controlled (moxifloxacin 400 mg). The study enrolled 50 healthy subjects with data of all periods. QT/RR hysteresis was assessed from prestudy exercise test ECGs. Among others, comparisons were made between population heart rate correction without hysteresis considerations and combined population heart rate and hysteresis correction.
The highest heart rate increase (placebo and baseline controlled) of 13.1 beats per minute (90% CI 9.9-16.4) occurred 1 minute after the administration of the highest dose of gadobutrol. Without hysteresis consideration, the highest DeltaDeltaQTc were 9.91 ms (90% CI 8.01-11.81) while with hysteresis correction, these values were 7.62 ms (90% CI 6.37-8.87), thus turning a marginally positive TQT study into a negative finding.
Hence, omitting hysteresis correction from episodes of fast heart rate changes may lead to incorrect conclusions. Despite substantial rate acceleration, accurate hysteresis correction confirms that gadobutrol does not have any effects on cardiac repolarization that would be within the limits of regulatory relevance.
每种新的药物化合物都需要进行所谓的全面QT/QTc(TQT)研究,如果安慰剂和基线校正QTc延长的单侧95%置信区间(CI)上限<10毫秒,则研究结果为阴性。这一严格要求有许多方法学上的影响。如果所研究的药物作用迅速,且无法在稳定心率下获取心电图,则需要进行QT/RR滞后校正。
这一方法用于钆布醇的TQT研究。该TQT研究是一项随机双盲的五交叉研究,涉及三种剂量的钆布醇(0.1、0.3和0.5 mmol/kg),以安慰剂和阳性对照(莫西沙星400毫克)。该研究招募了50名健康受试者,并获取了所有阶段的数据。通过研究前运动试验心电图评估QT/RR滞后。此外,还对未考虑滞后因素的总体心率校正与总体心率和滞后因素联合校正进行了比较。
在给予最高剂量钆布醇1分钟后,心率出现最高增加(安慰剂和基线对照),每分钟增加13.1次(90%CI 9.9-16.4)。未考虑滞后因素时,最大DeltaDeltaQTc为9.91毫秒(90%CI 8.01-11.81),而进行滞后校正后,这些值为7.62毫秒(90%CI 6.37-8.87),从而使一项边缘阳性的TQT研究变为阴性结果。
因此,在心率快速变化的情况下忽略滞后校正可能会导致错误的结论。尽管心率大幅加快,但准确的滞后校正证实钆布醇对心脏复极化没有任何超出监管相关范围的影响。