Menees Stacy B, Schoenfeld Philip, Kim Hyungjin Myra, Elta Grace H
Eastern Virginia Medical School, 885 Kempsville Rd, Suite 114, Norfolk, Virginia 23502, United States.
World J Gastroenterol. 2009 Jul 28;15(28):3486-92. doi: 10.3748/wjg.15.3486.
To investigate the endoscopic ampullectomy practices of expert biliary endoscopists.
An anonymous survey was mailed to 79 expert biliary endoscopists to assess ampullectomy practices.
Forty six (58%) biliary endoscopists returned the questionnaire. Of these, 63% were in academia and in practice for an average of 16.4 years (+/- 8.6). Endoscopists performed an average of 1.1 (+/- 0.8) ampullectomies per month. Prior to ampullectomy, endoscopic ultrasound was "always" utilized by 67% of respondents vs "sometimes" in 31% of respondents. Empiric biliary sphincterotomy was not utilized uniformly, only 26% "always" and 37% "sometimes" performed it prior to resection. Fifty three percent reported "never" performing empiric pancreatic sphincterotomy prior to ampullectomy. Practitioners with high endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography volumes were the most likely to perform a pancreatic sphincterotomy (OR = 10.9; P = 0.09). Participants overwhelmingly favored "always" placing a prophylactic pancreatic stent, with 86% placing it after ampullectomy rather than prior to resection (23%). Argon plasma coagulation was the favored adjunct modality (83%) for removal of residual adenomatous tissue. Practitioners uniformly (100%) preferred follow-up examination to be within 6 mo post-ampullectomy.
Among biliary experts, there is less variation in ampullectomy practices than is reflected in the literature.
调查胆道内镜专家的内镜下壶腹切除术操作情况。
向79位胆道内镜专家邮寄了一份匿名调查问卷,以评估壶腹切除术的操作情况。
46位(58%)胆道内镜专家回复了问卷。其中,63%在学术界工作,平均从业年限为16.4年(±8.6年)。内镜专家每月平均进行1.1例(±0.8例)壶腹切除术。在进行壶腹切除术之前,67%的受访者“总是”使用内镜超声,31%的受访者“有时”使用。经验性胆管括约肌切开术的使用并不统一,只有26%的人“总是”在切除术前进行,37%的人“有时”进行。53%的人报告在壶腹切除术之前“从未”进行过经验性胰管括约肌切开术。内镜逆行胰胆管造影术操作量高的从业者最有可能进行胰管括约肌切开术(比值比=10.9;P=0.09)。绝大多数参与者赞成“总是”放置预防性胰管支架,86%的人在壶腹切除术后放置,而不是在切除术前放置(23%)。氩等离子体凝固是去除残留腺瘤组织最常用的辅助方式(83%)。所有从业者(100%)都倾向于在壶腹切除术后6个月内进行随访检查。
在胆道专家中,壶腹切除术操作的差异比文献中所反映的要小。