Botelho-Nevers Elisabeth, Thuny Franck, Casalta Jean Paul, Richet Hervé, Gouriet Frédérique, Collart Frédéric, Riberi Alberto, Habib Gilbert, Raoult Didier
Laboratoire de Microbiologie, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Unite Mixte de Recherche 6236, Institut Fédératif de Recherche 48, Université de la Méditerranée, 13385 Marseille CEDEX 5, France.
Arch Intern Med. 2009 Jul 27;169(14):1290-8. doi: 10.1001/archinternmed.2009.192.
Despite improvements in medical and surgical therapy, infective endocarditis (IE) is still associated with a severe prognosis and remains a therapeutic challenge. We aimed to evaluate the impact of a standardized diagnostic and therapeutic protocol on mortality and to correlate the outcome with compliance with our management-based protocol.
We conducted an observational before-after study that included 333 consecutive patients treated for IE at a referral center from 1991 to 2006, which was divided into 2 periods: period 1 (1991-2001), before implementation of our therapeutic protocol (n = 173), and period 2 (2002-2006), after implementation of our protocol (n = 160). Our protocol was created by a multidisciplinary task force including a sampling of biological specimens, the use of only 4 antimicrobial agents, a standardized duration of treatment, standardized surgical indications, and 1 year of close follow-up. Because our protocol was based on a local consensus by physicians and surgeons, it was not possible to randomize the study.
The 1-year mortality significantly decreased from 18.5% during period 1 to 8.2% during period 2 (hazard ratio, 0.41; 95% confidence interval, 0.21-0.79 [P = .008]). After multivariable analysis, the management during period 2 remained a strong protective factor (adjusted hazard ratio, 0.26; 95% confidence interval, 0.09-0.76 [P = .01]). During period 2, we observed a statistically significantly better compliance in antimicrobial therapy and fewer cases of renal failure. Deaths by embolic events and multiple organ failure syndrome also significantly decreased during period 2.
A dramatic reduction in mortality was observed during this study, suggesting that a management-based approach has a significant impact on IE outcome.
尽管在内科及外科治疗方面已有所改善,但感染性心内膜炎(IE)的预后仍然严峻,仍是一个治疗难题。我们旨在评估标准化诊断和治疗方案对死亡率的影响,并将治疗结果与遵循我们基于管理的方案的情况相关联。
我们进行了一项前后对照观察性研究,纳入了1991年至2006年在一家转诊中心连续接受IE治疗的333例患者,分为两个时期:第1期(1991 - 2001年),在我们的治疗方案实施之前(n = 173);第2期(2002 - 2006年),在我们的方案实施之后(n = 160)。我们的方案由一个多学科特别工作组制定,包括生物标本采样、仅使用4种抗菌药物、标准化治疗时长、标准化手术指征以及1年的密切随访。由于我们的方案基于内科医生和外科医生的本地共识,因此无法对研究进行随机分组。
1年死亡率从第1期的18.5%显著降至第2期的8.2%(风险比,0.41;95%置信区间,0.21 - 0.79 [P = .008])。多变量分析后,第2期的治疗管理仍然是一个强有力的保护因素(调整后风险比,0.26;95%置信区间,0.09 - 0.76 [P = .01])。在第2期,我们观察到抗菌治疗的依从性在统计学上有显著改善,肾衰竭病例减少。第2期因栓塞事件和多器官功能衰竭综合征导致的死亡也显著减少。
在本研究中观察到死亡率显著降低,表明基于管理的方法对IE的治疗结果有重大影响。