Kusunoki Shinji, Tanigawa Koichi, Kondo Takashi, Kawamoto Masashi, Yuge Osafumi
Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care, Division of Clinical Medical Science, Graduate School of Biomedical Sciences, Hiroshima University, 1-2-3 Kasumi, Minami-ku, Hiroshima 734-8551, Japan.
Resuscitation. 2009 Oct;80(10):1175-80. doi: 10.1016/j.resuscitation.2009.06.030. Epub 2009 Jul 31.
No previous study has investigated the safety of hand position during chest compression determined by the inter-nipple line, in which the heel of one hand is positioned on the centre of the chest between the nipples, from the standpoint of prevention of organ injury.
We measured the distance from the xiphisternal junction to the inter-nipple line (dN) in 1000 surgical patients and the heel length (H) of hands in 100 healthy volunteers, then used the formula H/2-dN to determine the amount of deviation when the heel of the rescuer's hand extended to the xiphoid process (D). Next, 100 surgical patients were randomly assigned to 18 anaesthesiologists, who placed the heels of their hands on the sternum for validation.
The D value was positive in 551 patients, indicating that the heel may extend to the xiphoid process during chest compression in those individuals. Multivariate logistic-regression analyses showed that deviations beyond the xiphoid process to the epigastric region were more likely to occur in female (OR 3.52), elderly (OR 2.00), and short-statured (OR 2.09) patients, and with male rescuers (OR 2.81). During actual positioning, deviation occurred in 51 patients and extended to the epigastric region in 5 females.
Simulation of hand position determined by the inter-nipple line resulted in placement of the rescuer's hands over the xiphoid process in nearly half of the patients. Hand deviation to the epigastric region may occur when the patient is a short-statured or elderly female, and when the rescuer is male.
以往尚无研究从预防器官损伤的角度,调查通过乳头连线确定的胸外按压时手部位置的安全性,即一只手的掌根置于两乳头连线中点的胸部中央。
我们测量了1000例外科手术患者剑突与乳头连线之间的距离(dN),以及100名健康志愿者手部的掌根长度(H),然后使用公式H/2 - dN来确定施救者的手掌根延伸至剑突时的偏移量(D)。接下来,将100例外科手术患者随机分配给18名麻醉医生,由他们将手掌根置于胸骨上进行验证。
551例患者的D值为阳性,表明这些个体在胸外按压时手掌根可能会延伸至剑突。多因素逻辑回归分析显示,剑突以外至腹上部区域的偏移更有可能发生在女性(比值比3.52)、老年(比值比2.00)、身材矮小(比值比2.09)的患者以及男性施救者(比值比2.81)中。在实际定位过程中,51例患者出现偏移,其中5名女性延伸至腹上部区域。
通过乳头连线确定的手部位置模拟结果显示,近半数患者的施救者手部会置于剑突上方。当患者为身材矮小或老年女性且施救者为男性时,手部可能会向腹上部区域偏移。