University of Central Lancashire, Preston, UK.
Int J Soc Psychiatry. 2010 Jul;56(4):448-53. doi: 10.1177/0020764009342384. Epub 2009 Aug 3.
The main aims were to examine the relationship between general population suicide rates and the presence of national policies on mental health, funding for mental health, and measures of mental health service provision.
Data on general population suicide rates for both genders were obtained from the World Health Organization (WHO) databank available on the WHO website. Data on the presence of national policies on mental health, funding for mental health and measures of mental health service provision were obtained from the Mental Health Atlas 2005, also available on the WHO website.
The main findings were: (i) there was no relationship between suicide rates in both genders and different measures of mental health policy, except they were increased in countries with mental health legislation; (ii) there was a significant positive correlation between suicide rates in both genders and the percentage of the total health budget spent on mental health; and (iii) suicide rates in both genders were higher in countries with greater provision of mental health services, including the number of psychiatric beds, psychiatrists and psychiatric nurses, and the availability of training in mental health for primary care professionals.
Cross-national ecological studies using national-level aggregate data are not helpful in establishing a causal relationship (and the direction of this relationship) between suicide rates and mental health funding, service provision and national policies. The impact of introducing national policies on mental health, increasing funding for mental health services and increasing mental health service provision on suicide rates requires further examination in longitudinal within-country studies.
主要目的是检验一般人群自杀率与国家心理健康政策、心理健康资金投入以及心理健康服务提供措施之间的关系。
从世界卫生组织(WHO)网站上的 WHO 数据库中获取了两性的一般人群自杀率数据。从世界卫生组织网站上的《2005 年心理健康地图集》中获取了国家心理健康政策、心理健康资金投入以及心理健康服务提供措施的数据。
主要发现为:(i)除了心理健康立法的国家自杀率增加外,两性自杀率与不同的心理健康政策措施之间没有关系;(ii)两性自杀率与用于心理健康的总卫生预算的百分比之间存在显著的正相关关系;(iii)心理健康服务提供更多的国家,包括精神科病床、精神科医生和精神科护士的数量以及初级保健专业人员精神卫生培训的提供情况,两性自杀率更高。
使用国家级汇总数据的跨国生态研究无助于确定自杀率与心理健康资金投入、服务提供和国家政策之间的因果关系(以及这种关系的方向)。需要进一步在国家内的纵向研究中检验实施国家心理健康政策、增加心理健康服务资金投入和增加心理健康服务提供对自杀率的影响。