Huang Ya-Yi, Gau Meei-Ling, Huang Chiu-Mieh, Lee Jian-Tao
Department of Nursing, Tungs' Taichung MetroHarbor Hospital, Taichung, Taiwan.
Chang Gung Med J. 2009 Jul-Aug;32(4):423-31.
Few studies have provided evidence to verify that bottle-feeding has negative effects on breastfeeding. There is insufficient evidence to support the practice of cup-feeding to supplement breastfeeding. However, it has been applied as a substitute for bottle-feeding to promote breastfeeding. The aims of this study were to explore the differences in infant sucking competence, infant sucking behavior and maternal milk supply among babies who were exclusively breastfeeding (breast group), breast feeding with cup supplementation (cup group) and breast-feeding with bottle supplementation (bottle group) at different periods postpartum.
A longitudinal study was carried out at a medical center located in northern Taiwan. The cup and bottle groups were recruited at two different times to avoid interaction. The breast group consisted of infants who were fully breastfed and were never exposed to a bottle or a cup during the hospital stay. Two hundred and five healthy mothers and their full-term, singletoninfants were eligible for enrollment. We used structured questionnaires and made observations to obtain information on breastfeeding at the first breastfeeding and the third day after birth, and then followed up these cases at two and four weeks.
The bottle group was significantly more fretful during breastfeeding (p< .01). Mothers in the bottle group perceived that their milk supply was less sufficient than those in breast and cup groups (p < .01).
Some indicators of breastfeeding were similar in the breast and cup groups. Cup-feeding was better than bottle-feeding when supplementary formula was needed for medical treatment.
很少有研究提供证据证实奶瓶喂养对母乳喂养有负面影响。没有足够的证据支持使用杯子喂养来补充母乳喂养的做法。然而,它已被用作奶瓶喂养的替代方法以促进母乳喂养。本研究的目的是探讨产后不同时期纯母乳喂养婴儿(母乳喂养组)、杯子补充母乳喂养婴儿(杯子组)和奶瓶补充母乳喂养婴儿(奶瓶组)在婴儿吸吮能力、婴儿吸吮行为和母亲乳汁供应方面的差异。
在位于台湾北部的一家医疗中心进行了一项纵向研究。杯子组和奶瓶组在两个不同时间招募以避免相互影响。母乳喂养组由完全母乳喂养且在住院期间从未接触过奶瓶或杯子的婴儿组成。205名健康母亲及其足月单胎婴儿符合纳入条件。我们使用结构化问卷并进行观察,以获取出生后首次母乳喂养和第三天时母乳喂养的信息,然后在两周和四周时对这些病例进行随访。
奶瓶组在母乳喂养期间明显更烦躁(p <.01)。奶瓶组的母亲认为她们的乳汁供应比母乳喂养组和杯子组的母亲更不足(p <.01)。
母乳喂养组和杯子组的一些母乳喂养指标相似。在因医疗需要补充配方奶时,杯子喂养优于奶瓶喂养。