Ertem Ilgi Ozturk, Pekcici Emine Bahar Bingoler, Gok Canan Gul, Ozbas Sema, Ozcebe Hilal, Beyazova Ufuk
Department of Pediatrics, Developmental-Behavioral Pediatrics Unit, Ankara University School of Medicine, Ankara, 06100 Turkey.
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 2009 Aug;30(4):319-26. doi: 10.1097/DBP.0b013e3181b0f035.
This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of a national training program in Turkey in improving primary health providers' knowledge and perceived competence about the promotion of early childhood development and prevention, early identification and management of developmental problems; and barriers to implementation and sustainability of skills gained.
A pre-post intervention design was used. Tools measuring perceived competence and knowledge about childhood development were administered to primary health providers before and after training. Immediate skills were observed, and implementation and sustainability of skills were determined using individual surveys and focus group discussions 1 year after training.
The training was provided in 5 provinces. Of the 148 primary health providers trained, 90% had >5 years experience in providing primary care. Median knowledge test scores were 13 pretraining and increased to 22 posttraining (p < 0.001). Median perceived competence scores increased from 159 to 222 (p < 0.001). A year after the training, the program and materials were reported to be valued and remembered but used limitedly. Patient load, insufficient time allocated to primary care, lack of reimbursement, and ineffective referrals to pediatricians who had knowledge gaps regarding child development were identified as important barriers to implementation and sustainability of skills gained.
In Turkey and potentially other countries with similar health systems, short-term inservice training on child development can improve primary health providers' knowledge, perceived competence and skills related to child development. To decrease the disparities between high- and low- and middle-income countries in addressing child development, significant barriers within health systems need to be identified and addressed.
本研究旨在评估土耳其一项全国性培训项目在提高初级卫生保健人员关于促进儿童早期发展及预防、早期识别和管理发育问题的知识和感知能力方面的效果;以及所获技能在实施和可持续性方面的障碍。
采用干预前后设计。在培训前后,向初级卫生保健人员发放测量其关于儿童发育的感知能力和知识的工具。观察即时技能,并在培训1年后通过个人调查和焦点小组讨论确定技能的实施和可持续性情况。
培训在5个省份开展。在接受培训的148名初级卫生保健人员中,90%在提供初级保健方面有超过5年的经验。知识测试中位数得分在培训前为13分,培训后增至22分(p<0.001)。感知能力中位数得分从159分提高到222分(p<0.001)。培训1年后,该项目和材料被认为有价值且令人印象深刻,但使用有限。患者数量、分配给初级保健的时间不足、缺乏报销以及向对儿童发育存在知识差距的儿科医生转诊无效被确定为所获技能在实施和可持续性方面的重要障碍。
在土耳其以及可能其他具有类似卫生系统的国家,关于儿童发育的短期在职培训可以提高初级卫生保健人员与儿童发育相关的知识、感知能力和技能。为了减少高收入国家与低收入和中等收入国家在解决儿童发育问题上的差距,需要识别并解决卫生系统内的重大障碍。