Joyce Geoffrey F, Goldman Dana P, Vogt William B, Sun Eric, Jena Anupam B
RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA 90407-2138, USA.
Am J Manag Care. 2009 Aug;15(8):536-44.
To assess the broad impacts of Medicare Part D and the extent to which prior concerns have been realized.
We used administrative data to summarize beneficiary enrollment and plan participation in Part D, and compared pharmaceutical use and out-of-pocket spending before and after the introduction of Part D. We characterized the benefit designs of the 10 largest Part D plans in 2006 and compared them with the benefit designs of 7 non-Part D plans often cited as examples of low-cost or comprehensive drug benefits.
By 2008, nearly 90% of seniors had drug coverage at least as generous as the standard Part D benefit. Excluding premiums, annual out-of-pocket spending in the 10 largest Part D plans was comparable to that of other private and public drug benefits, with the most prominent differences attributable to out-of-pocket spending on drugs not covered in the plan. Poorer beneficiaries have gained the most from Part D in terms of increased access to medications and reduced out-of-pocket spending.
Coverage under Part D is comparable to that under non-Part D plans with respect to key features that are likely to be important to Medicare beneficiaries--access to medications and out-of-pocket costs. Nonetheless, concerns remain over drug pricing and gaps in coverage. The government should continue to monitor the competitiveness of the Part D market to ensure it meets the diverse needs of Medicare beneficiaries.
评估医疗保险D部分的广泛影响以及先前担忧得以实现的程度。
我们使用行政数据总结了D部分的受益人参保情况和计划参与情况,并比较了D部分推出前后的药品使用和自付费用。我们对2006年最大的10个D部分计划的福利设计进行了特征描述,并将它们与7个常被引为低成本或全面药品福利示例的非D部分计划的福利设计进行了比较。
到2008年,近90%的老年人拥有至少与标准D部分福利一样慷慨的药品保险。排除保费后,最大的10个D部分计划中的年度自付费用与其他私人和公共药品福利相当,最显著的差异归因于计划未涵盖药品的自付费用。就增加药品获取和减少自付费用而言,较贫困的受益人从D部分中获益最多。
在可能对医疗保险受益人很重要的关键特征——药品获取和自付费用方面,D部分的保险与非D部分计划的保险相当。尽管如此,对药品定价和保险缺口的担忧仍然存在。政府应继续监测D部分市场的竞争力,以确保其满足医疗保险受益人的多样化需求。