Taylor Eric G, Ross Brian H
Department of Psychology, University of Illinois, 603 East Daniel Street, Champaign, IL 61820, USA.
J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn. 2009 Sep;35(5):1374-80. doi: 10.1037/a0016568.
Categories underlie a variety of functions beyond just classification, including inference and explanation. To classify, people need to distinguish between categories, but other functions rely on within-category information (things true of a particular category, independent of others). Despite the need for both types of knowledge, recent work shows that classification does not lead to learning an important type of within-category information, prototypical nondiagnostic information. However, most classification studies are conducted under narrow conditions that do not cover many basic ways that people learn categories. In 2 experiments, the authors compared standard classification learning with a slightly different task where items appeared with occluded features (as many objects appear); they hypothesized that this change might lead to broader attention and learning of within-category, prototypical nondiagnostic information. The results support this prediction, offering evidence that classification can lead to learning within-category information. They discuss the possibility that other classification results may depend on specifics of the standard paradigm.
类别所具有的功能远不止分类,还包括推理和解释等多种功能。为了进行分类,人们需要区分不同的类别,但其他功能则依赖于类别内部的信息(特定类别所具有的、独立于其他类别的特征)。尽管这两种知识都有必要,但最近的研究表明,分类并不能促使人们学习到一种重要的类别内部信息,即原型非诊断性信息。然而,大多数分类研究都是在狭窄的条件下进行的,并未涵盖人们学习类别的许多基本方式。在两项实验中,作者将标准分类学习与一项稍有不同的任务进行了比较,在该任务中,项目呈现时带有遮挡特征(就像许多物体呈现的那样);他们推测这种变化可能会导致更广泛的关注,并促使人们学习类别内部的原型非诊断性信息。结果支持了这一预测,提供了证据表明分类可以促使人们学习类别内部信息。他们讨论了其他分类结果可能取决于标准范式具体细节的可能性。