Birnbaum Rena, Limperopoulos Catherine
Montreal Children's Hospital, 2300 Tupper St., Montreal, QC, Canada.
Adv Neonatal Care. 2009 Aug;9(4):180-4. doi: 10.1097/ANC.0b013e3181aa9c65.
The purpose of this study was to delineate current practice for the selection of nonoral feeding routes in level III neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) across Canada.
All level III Canadian NICUs (n = 28).
A written questionnaire was developed specifically for gathering data in the NICU about the current method of selection of feeding tubes.
We surveyed, by telephone, charge nurses at all level III NICUs to elucidate the current use of orogastric (OG) versus nasogastric (NG) route of tube for fullterm and preterm infants.
The results from this study indicate that 75% percent of NICUs in Canada primarily used NG tubes. Pediatric institutions were significantly more likely to use NG (>75% of the time) (P = .003). All of the centers (100%) using NG tubes used indwelling tubes. Only 18% of centers selected OG tubes primarily. Nonpediatric institutions were significantly more likely to use OG tubes (P = .001). Ten percent of NICUs reported using both NG and OG tubes equally. There was no difference indicated on selection of tube for preterm babies versus term babies. However, there was 100% agreement in the use of OG tubes in infants with structural anomalies of the nares or if the infants were on continuous positive airway pressure. Overall, decision regarding route of tube was made primarily according to physician preference and the natural history and experience within the NICU.
The results of this survey indicate that there are no clear clinical guidelines currently in place to determine route of feeding tubes in NICUs across Canada. Physician preference or history of the institution appears to be the most important variable in determining tube selection. Given the high prevalence of acute and chronic feeding difficulties among NICU survivors, the choice of route of tube should be guided by specific evidence-based criteria.
本研究旨在描述加拿大三级新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)选择非经口喂养途径的当前做法。
加拿大所有三级NICU(n = 28)。
专门设计了一份书面问卷,用于收集NICU中关于喂养管选择的当前方法的数据。
我们通过电话调查了所有三级NICU的责任护士,以阐明足月和早产儿经口胃管(OG)与鼻胃管(NG)途径的当前使用情况。
本研究结果表明,加拿大75%的NICU主要使用鼻胃管。儿科机构使用鼻胃管的可能性显著更高(超过75%的时间)(P = 0.003)。所有使用鼻胃管的中心(100%)都使用留置管。只有18%的中心主要选择经口胃管。非儿科机构使用经口胃管的可能性显著更高(P = 0.001)。10%的NICU报告称同等程度地使用鼻胃管和经口胃管。在为早产儿和足月儿选择喂养管方面没有差异。然而,对于鼻孔结构异常的婴儿或接受持续气道正压通气的婴儿,在使用经口胃管方面达成了100%的共识。总体而言,关于喂养管途径的决定主要根据医生的偏好以及NICU内的自然情况和经验做出。
本次调查结果表明,目前加拿大各地的NICU在确定喂养管途径方面没有明确的临床指南。医生的偏好或机构的历史似乎是决定喂养管选择的最重要变量。鉴于NICU幸存者中急性和慢性喂养困难的高发生率,喂养管途径的选择应以特定的循证标准为指导。