Nowaczewska W, Kuźmiński L
Department of Anthropology, University of WrocŁaw, ul. Kuźnicza 35, 50-138 WrocŁaw, Poland.
Homo. 2009;60(6):489-516. doi: 10.1016/j.jchb.2009.08.004. Epub 2009 Sep 24.
The occipital bun is widely considered a Neanderthal feature. Its homology to the 'hemibun' observed in some European Upper Palaeolithic anatomically modern humans is a current problem. This study quantitatively evaluates the degree of occipital plane convexity in African and Australian modern human crania to analyse a relationship between this feature and some neurocranial variables. Neanderthal and European Upper Palaeolithic Homo sapiens crania were included in the analysis as well. The results of this study indicated that there is a significant relationship between the degree of occipital plane convexity and the following two features in the examined crania of modern humans: the ratio of the maximum neurocranial height to the maximum width of the vault and the ratio of bregma-lambda chord to bregma-lambda arc. The results also revealed that some H. sapiens crania (modern and fossil) show the Neanderthal shape of the occipital plane and that the neurocranial height and shape of parietal midsagittal profile has an influence on occipital plane convexity in the hominins included in this study. This study suggests that the occurrence of the great convexity of the occipital plane in the Neanderthals and H. sapiens is a "by-product" of the relationship between the same neurocranial features and there is no convincing evidence that the Neanderthal occipital bun and the similar structure in H. sapiens develop during ontogeny in the same way.
枕部发髻被广泛认为是尼安德特人的一个特征。它与在一些欧洲旧石器时代晚期解剖学意义上的现代人类中观察到的“半发髻”的同源性是当前一个问题。本研究定量评估了非洲和澳大利亚现代人类颅骨枕平面凸度的程度,以分析这一特征与一些脑颅变量之间的关系。分析中还纳入了尼安德特人和欧洲旧石器时代晚期智人的颅骨。本研究结果表明,在被检查的现代人类颅骨中,枕平面凸度程度与以下两个特征之间存在显著关系:脑颅最大高度与颅顶最大宽度的比值以及前囟-枕外隆凸弦长与前囟-枕外隆凸弧长的比值。结果还显示,一些智人颅骨(现代的和化石的)呈现出尼安德特人枕平面的形状,并且本研究中所涉及的人类的脑颅高度和顶骨矢状中线轮廓形状对枕平面凸度有影响。本研究表明,尼安德特人和智人中枕平面的大凸度的出现是相同脑颅特征之间关系的“副产品”,并且没有令人信服的证据表明尼安德特人的枕部发髻和智人中的类似结构在个体发育过程中以相同方式发育。