Comparison of different methods of ventilation via cannula cricothyroidotomy in a trachea-lung model.

BACKGROUND

Cannula cricothyroidotomy is recommended in recent guidelines as a rescue intervention in the 'cannot-intubate cannot-ventilate' scenario. Several methods of providing ventilation via a cannula cricothyroidotomy have been described, but there are no data comparing these methods and using cannulae of differing diameters.

METHODS

Using a bench-top trachea-lung model (comprising a Siemens test lung attached to commercially available breathing system tubing), we compared delivered minute volumes (MVs) for five methods of ventilation administered through cannulae of diameters 20, 16, 14, and 13 G. The ventilation methods were: an ENK oxygen flow modulator, a Manujet, a self-inflating resuscitation bag, the oxygen flush of an anaesthetic machine, and oxygen from a wall-mounted flow meter attached via a three-way tap to the cannula. All experiments were performed with and without a proximal 2.5 mm diameter constriction to simulate partial upper airway obstruction.

RESULTS

MVs increased with increasing cannula diameter. In the absence of a proximal constriction, MVs delivered via a 20 G cannula were <1 litre min(-1) with all devices; only the Manujet delivered MVs >2 litre min(-1), at cannula sizes of >or=16 G. MVs were greater in the presence of a proximal constriction, but did not exceed 4 litre min(-1) using the low-pressure devices.

CONCLUSIONS

Extrapolated to the clinical situation, these data suggest that low-pressure devices will not deliver adequate MVs via a cannula cricothroidotomy and should no longer be advocated. Purpose-made devices should be available in all areas where anaesthesia is administered or airway interventions are performed.