School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720-7360, USA.
Health Educ Behav. 2010 Jun;37(3):424-51. doi: 10.1177/1090198109342084. Epub 2009 Oct 1.
Although a growing number of projects have been implemented using the community-based participatory research method known as photovoice, no known systematic review of the literature on this approach has been conducted to date. This review draws on the peer-reviewed literature on photovoice in public health and related disciplines conducted before January 2008 to determine (a) what defines the photovoice process, (b) the outcomes associated with photovoice, and (c) how the level of community participation is related to photovoice processes and outcomes. In all, 37 unduplicated articles were identified and reviewed using a descriptive coding scheme and Viswanathan et al.'s quality of participation tool. Findings reveal no relationship between group size and quality of participation but a direct relationship between the latter and project duration as well as with getting to action. More participatory projects also were associated with long-standing relationships between the community and outside researcher partners and an intensive training component. Although vague descriptions of project evaluation practices and a lack of consistent reporting precluded hard conclusions, 60% of projects reported an action component. Particularly among highly participatory projects, photovoice appears to contribute to an enhanced understanding of community assets and needs and to empowerment.
虽然越来越多的项目已经采用了基于社区的参与式研究方法,即摄影展,但迄今为止,尚未对这种方法的文献进行系统评价。本综述借鉴了 2008 年 1 月之前在公共卫生和相关学科领域进行的关于摄影展的同行评议文献,以确定:(a) 摄影展过程的定义;(b) 与摄影展相关的结果;以及 (c) 社区参与程度与摄影展过程和结果的关系。共有 37 篇非重复文章被确定,并使用描述性编码方案和 Viswanathan 等人的参与质量工具进行了审查。研究结果表明,群体规模与参与质量之间没有关系,但后者与项目持续时间以及采取行动之间存在直接关系。更具参与性的项目还与社区和外部研究伙伴之间的长期关系以及密集的培训部分有关。尽管项目评估实践的描述模糊不清,以及缺乏一致的报告,使得难以得出明确的结论,但 60%的项目报告了一个行动部分。特别是在高度参与的项目中,摄影展似乎有助于增强对社区资产和需求的理解,并赋予其权力。