Sugeno H
Department of Forensic Medicine, Kanagawa Dental College.
Kanagawa Shigaku. 1990 Dec;25(3):306-15.
On the age estimation by the amino acid racemization analysis of dentin, besides the utilization of aspartic acid (Asp) as described in earlier reports, we further studied relationships between the D/L ratios based on glutamic acid (Glu) as well as alanine (Ala) and actual ages. The study was followed up by comparing racemization velocities of the three amino acids under some heating experiments. At four steps (6, 24, 48 and 72 hours) of hydrolysis, the coefficient values of D/L ratio of each amino acid and actual age were calculated as 0.986 to 0.994 for Asp, 0.522 to 0.806 for Glu, and 0.577 to 0.737 for Ala. The data indicate that Asp gives an extremely good result. Glu and Ala do provide reliable D/L ratios, however they are not in proportion to actual ages. Consequently, Glu and Ala seem to be much less suitable for utilization in age estimation. Reaction rate constants (k.yr-1) of racemization of Asp, Glu and Ala in antemortem teeth were 5.3825 x 10(-4), 5.1000 x 10(-5) and 2.3875 x 10(-5), respectively. Those in teeth left drying at 15 degrees C were 2.4850 x 10(-8), 1.9119 x 10(-9), and 1.11450 x 10(-9), respectively. Assuming that the reaction velocity of Asp be 1 in both living and dry states, that of Glu were calculated as 0.09 and 0.08, that of Ala, 0.04 and 0.05, indicating very similar rates. The result confirmed that both Glu and Ala gave considerably slow racemization velocities as compared with Asp.
关于通过牙本质氨基酸消旋分析进行年龄估计,除了如早期报告中所述利用天冬氨酸(Asp)外,我们还进一步研究了基于谷氨酸(Glu)以及丙氨酸(Ala)的D/L比值与实际年龄之间的关系。通过比较三种氨基酸在一些加热实验中的消旋速度对该研究进行了跟进。在水解的四个步骤(6、24、48和72小时)中,计算出每种氨基酸的D/L比值与实际年龄的系数值,Asp为0.986至0.994,Glu为0.522至0.806,Ala为0.577至0.737。数据表明Asp给出了非常好的结果。Glu和Ala确实提供了可靠的D/L比值,然而它们与实际年龄不成比例。因此,Glu和Ala似乎不太适合用于年龄估计。生前牙齿中Asp、Glu和Ala的消旋反应速率常数(k.yr-1)分别为5.3825×10(-4)、5.1000×10(-5)和2.3875×10(-5)。在15℃下干燥的牙齿中的反应速率常数分别为2.4850×10(-8)、1.9119×10(-9)和1.11450×10(-9)。假设Asp在活体和干燥状态下的反应速度均为1,则Glu的反应速度计算为0.09和0.08,Ala的反应速度为0.04和0.05,表明速率非常相似。结果证实,与Asp相比,Glu和Ala的消旋速度都相当慢。