Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital, Enugu, Nigeria.
BMC Womens Health. 2009 Oct 23;9:30. doi: 10.1186/1472-6874-9-30.
Effective management of menopause is an important way to improve the quality of life of the increasing number of older women. The study sought to find out if Nigerian Gynaecologists offer effective treatment for severe menopausal symptoms.
126 Nigerian Gynaecologists representing the six health zones of Nigeria were interviewed to determine the menopausal symptoms they had ever encountered in their practices, frequency of the symptoms, treatments ever offered for severe symptoms including their attitude to, and practice of hormone replacement therapy.
A Nigerian Gynaecologist encountered an average of one patient with menopausal symptoms every three months (range: 0-3 patients per month). The commoner symptoms they encountered were hot flushes (88%), insomnia (75.4%), depression (58.0%), irritability (56.3%), night sweats (55.6%) and muscle pains (54.8%) while urinary symptoms (16.7%) and fracture (1.6%) were less common. Treatments ever offered for severe symptoms were reassurance (90.5%), anxiolytics (68.3%), analgesics (14.3), HRT (7.9%), Vitamins (4%), Beta-blockers (3.2%) and Danazol (2.4%). These treatments were offered as a matter of institutional traditions rather than being based on any evidence of their efficacy.
The result revealed that most Nigerian Gynaecologists prefer reassurance and anxiolytics for managing severe menopausal symptoms instead of evidence-based effective therapies. A policy of mandatory continuing medical education for Nigerian physicians is recommended to ensure evidence-based management of gynaecological problems, including menopause.
有效管理更年期是提高越来越多老年女性生活质量的重要途径。本研究旨在了解尼日利亚妇科医生是否为严重更年期症状提供有效治疗。
对代表尼日利亚六个卫生区的 126 名尼日利亚妇科医生进行了访谈,以了解他们在实践中遇到的更年期症状、症状发生频率、为严重症状提供的治疗方法,包括他们对激素替代疗法的态度和实践。
尼日利亚妇科医生平均每三个月遇到一位有更年期症状的患者(范围:每月 0-3 位患者)。他们遇到的常见症状有热潮红(88%)、失眠(75.4%)、抑郁(58.0%)、易怒(56.3%)、盗汗(55.6%)和肌肉疼痛(54.8%),而泌尿系统症状(16.7%)和骨折(1.6%)则较少见。为严重症状提供的治疗方法包括安慰(90.5%)、抗焦虑药(68.3%)、镇痛药(14.3%)、HRT(7.9%)、维生素(4%)、β-受体阻滞剂(3.2%)和达那唑(2.4%)。这些治疗方法是基于机构传统提供的,而不是基于其疗效的任何证据。
结果表明,大多数尼日利亚妇科医生更喜欢使用安慰和抗焦虑药来治疗严重的更年期症状,而不是基于循证的有效治疗方法。建议对尼日利亚医生实行强制性继续医学教育政策,以确保包括更年期在内的妇科问题的循证管理。