Helms L B, Helms C M
College of Education, University of Iowa, Iowa City 52242.
Acad Med. 1991 Jan;66(1):1-7. doi: 10.1097/00001888-199101000-00001.
An analysis of reported state and federal adjudication from 1950 through 1989 was undertaken to identify trends in litigation involving medical students and undergraduate medical education. Of the 110 decisions cited, 51 (46%) involved disputes over general educational issues. A majority of the decisions affecting general education involved admissions and dismissal processes. Recently courts have begun scrutinizing readmission, course repetition, and cheating. Medical schools have accommodated to judicial scrutiny of general educational issues and have prevailed more often than claimants in litigation during this period, but litigation has not decreased as precedent and procedure have become clearer. Instead, litigation has continued unabated in alternative areas and at different levels of the educational process.
对1950年至1989年期间报告的州和联邦判决进行了分析,以确定涉及医学生和本科医学教育的诉讼趋势。在所引用的110项判决中,51项(46%)涉及普通教育问题的争议。影响普通教育的大多数判决涉及招生和开除程序。最近,法院开始审查重新入学、课程重修和作弊问题。医学院校已经适应了对普通教育问题的司法审查,在此期间的诉讼中比原告胜诉的次数更多,但随着先例和程序变得更加清晰,诉讼并未减少。相反,在教育过程的其他领域和不同层面,诉讼仍未减弱地持续着。