Dr. Kamran Hafeez, FCPS, Assistant Professor Orthopedics, Dow International Medical College, Karachi, Pakistan.
Dr. Muhammad Laiq-uz-Zaman Khan, FCPS, Assistant Professor Surgery, Dow International Medical College, Dow University Hospital, Ojha Campus, KDA Scheme 33, Gulzar-e-Hijri, Suparco Road, Karachi, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2013 May;29(3):699-702. doi: 10.12669/pjms.293.3300.
To determine the trends of academic misconduct in undergraduate students of different private and government section medical institutes.
This cross sectional study was conducted at three medical colleges of Karachi, Pakistan. The students were evaluated by giving a self reported questionnaire containing various questions assessing their educational dishonesty and cheating behaviors.
A total of 274 students from different years completed the questionnaire. Mean age was 21.48 ± 1.89 years. Most of the students were in 4(th) year (n=86; 31.3%). There were 182 (66.5%) females and 92 (33.5%) males. Majority of the students (n=155; 55.1%) accepted that they have cheated at least once. There was no significant difference regarding acceptance of cheating among different years of study (p=0.23) however females were found to accept cheating more as compared to males (p=0.036). First year students were found more to ask teachers for answers during OSCE (p=0.01). A large number of students accepted that they mark proxy for their friends (85.7%) and also ask their friends to mark proxy for them (85.03%). Nearly half (44.02%) of the students rotating in wards also admitted to write fake histories.
A large number of medical students admitted cheating and involvement in other academic misconduct. We need to improve our educational system, formally add professional session and strict disciplinary action should be taken against those who are found guilty.
确定不同私立和政府医学院本科生学术不端行为的趋势。
本横断面研究在巴基斯坦卡拉奇的三所医学院进行。通过一份自我报告问卷评估学生,该问卷包含各种问题,评估他们的教育不诚实和作弊行为。
共有 274 名来自不同年级的学生完成了问卷。平均年龄为 21.48±1.89 岁。大多数学生在四年级(n=86;31.3%)。有 182 名(66.5%)女性和 92 名(33.5%)男性。大多数学生(n=155;55.1%)承认他们至少作弊过一次。不同年级的学生在接受作弊方面没有显著差异(p=0.23),但女性比男性更倾向于接受作弊(p=0.036)。在 OSCE 期间,一年级学生更倾向于向老师寻求答案(p=0.01)。大量学生承认他们为朋友代考(85.7%),也请朋友为他们代考(85.03%)。近一半(44.02%)在病房轮转的学生也承认写虚假病史。
大量医学生承认作弊和参与其他学术不端行为。我们需要改进我们的教育系统,正式增加专业课程,并对那些被发现有罪的人采取严格的纪律处分。