McAuliffe W E, Rohman M, Breer P, Wyshak G, Santangelo S, Magnuson E
Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Cambridge Hospital, MA 02139.
Am J Public Health. 1991 Feb;81(2):177-82. doi: 10.2105/ajph.81.2.177.
This study sought to resolve conflicting views about whether physicians are especially prone to alcohol abuse.
Using an anonymous, mailed questionnaire on substance use, we surveyed 500 physicians, 510 pharmacists, and 974 of their students. The physicians and pharmacists were selected randomly from the state society's membership lists, and students selected were from local school lists. Follow-up surveys were sent to nonresponders at two-week intervals.
The physicians and medical students did not drink especially heavily and were no more vulnerable to alcoholism than were their counterparts in pharmacy and other professions. Physicians differed from pharmacists in their style of drinking (greater frequency, smaller quantity), but not in total amount of alcohol consumed. Drinking habits among physicians were not associated with medical specialty or type of practice, but were positively related to gender (males drank more than females) and to age (older doctors were more apt to qualify as heavy drinkers than were younger doctors).
Physicians were no more likely to abuse substances nonmedically than were other professionals. Any group in which alcohol use is nearly universal incurs a risk of abuse and impairment that cannot be ignored.
本研究旨在解决关于医生是否特别容易酗酒的相互矛盾的观点。
我们使用一份关于物质使用的匿名邮寄问卷,对500名医生、510名药剂师及其974名学生进行了调查。医生和药剂师从州协会的会员名单中随机选取,学生则从当地学校名单中选取。每隔两周向未回复者发送后续调查问卷。
医生和医学生饮酒并不特别严重,在患酒精中毒方面并不比药剂师和其他职业的同行更易受影响。医生与药剂师在饮酒方式上存在差异(频率更高、量更小),但在饮酒总量上并无差异。医生的饮酒习惯与医学专业或执业类型无关,但与性别(男性饮酒多于女性)和年龄呈正相关(年长医生比年轻医生更有可能被认定为酗酒者)。
医生非医疗性滥用物质的可能性并不比其他专业人员更高。任何一个几乎普遍饮酒的群体都存在不可忽视的滥用和损害风险。