Department of Health Policy, National Research Institute for Child Health and Development, Tokyo, Japan.
J Epidemiol. 2010;20(1):54-61. doi: 10.2188/jea.je20081017. Epub 2009 Nov 14.
The strength of the association between brain tumors in children and residential power-frequency magnetic fields (MF) has varied in previous studies, which may be due in part to possible misclassification of MF exposure. This study aimed to examine this association in Japan by improving measurement techniques, and by extending measurement to a whole week.
This population-based case-control study encompassed 54% of Japanese children under 15 years of age. After excluding ineligible targeted children, 55 newly diagnosed brain tumor cases and 99 sex-, age-, and residential area-matched controls were included in the analyses. The MF exposures of each set of matching cases and controls were measured in close temporal proximity to control for seasonal variation; the average difference was 12.4 days. The mean interval between diagnosis and MF measurements was 1.1 years. The weekly mean MF level was defined as the exposure. The association was evaluated using conditional logistic regression analysis that controlled for possible confounding factors.
The odds ratios (95% CI) for exposure categories of 0.1 to 0.2, 0.2 to 0.4, and above 0.4 microT, against a reference category of <0.1 microT, were 0.74 (0.17-3.18), 1.58 (0.25-9.83), and 10.9 (1.05-113), respectively, after adjusting for maternal education. This dose-response pattern was stable when other variables were included in the model as possible confounding factors.
A positive association was found between high-level exposure-above 0.4 microT-and the risk of brain tumors. This association could not be explained solely by confounding factors or selection bias.
儿童脑肿瘤与居住环境工频磁场(MF)之间的关联强度在以往的研究中有所不同,部分原因可能是 MF 暴露的可能分类错误。本研究旨在通过改进测量技术并将测量扩展到整周来检验日本的这种关联。
这项基于人群的病例对照研究涵盖了 15 岁以下日本儿童的 54%。在排除不合格的目标儿童后,将 55 名新诊断的脑肿瘤病例和 99 名性别、年龄和居住区域匹配的对照纳入分析。在密切的时间接近度下测量每组匹配病例和对照的 MF 暴露情况,以控制季节性变化;平均差异为 12.4 天。诊断和 MF 测量之间的平均间隔为 1.1 年。每周平均 MF 水平被定义为暴露。使用条件逻辑回归分析评估关联,该分析控制了可能的混杂因素。
在调整了母亲教育水平后,暴露类别为 0.1 至 0.2、0.2 至 0.4 和大于 0.4 μT 的比值比(95%CI)分别为 0.74(0.17-3.18)、1.58(0.25-9.83)和 10.9(1.05-113)。当将其他变量作为可能的混杂因素纳入模型时,这种剂量-反应模式是稳定的。
发现高水平暴露(大于 0.4 μT)与脑肿瘤风险之间存在正相关。这种关联不能仅用混杂因素或选择偏差来解释。