Drake R E, Wallach M A, Teague G B, Freeman D H, Paskus T S, Clark T A
New Hampshire-Dartmouth Psychiatric Research Center.
Am J Psychiatry. 1991 Mar;148(3):330-6. doi: 10.1176/ajp.148.3.330.
The authors examined housing instability among treated schizophrenic patients in a rural area and compared the findings with those from their previous study of urban patients.
Seventy-five patients with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder who were treated in a rural mental health center were assessed with research interviews and ratings by their clinical case managers. The patients were followed for 1 year to identify episodes of psychiatric hospitalization, incarceration, and literal homelessness.
Of the 75 patients, 19 (25%) had housing situations characterized as unstable by their case managers. For the majority, housing instability signified tenuousness of living arrangements rather than literal homelessness. Noncompliance with medications, alcohol use, and negative symptoms accounted for 30% of the variance in unstable housing. During follow-up, the unstably housed patients, compared to those in stable living situations, were no more likely to be rehospitalized but were somewhat more likely to be jailed and significantly more likely to be literally homeless.
In the authors' previous study of urban psychiatric patients, unstably housed patients were more likely to be literally homeless, highly symptomatic, and rehospitalized during follow-up than the rural patients with unstable housing. Better outcomes in the rural area appeared to be related to the greater availability of housing alternatives and to intensive case management. For patients with unstable housing in both settings, noncompliance with medications and substance abuse, as well as housing arrangements, should be assertively addressed.
作者调查了农村地区接受治疗的精神分裂症患者的住房不稳定情况,并将结果与其之前对城市患者的研究结果进行比较。
对在农村心理健康中心接受治疗的75名精神分裂症或分裂情感性障碍患者进行了研究访谈,并由其临床病例管理人员进行评分。对这些患者进行了为期1年的随访,以确定精神科住院、监禁和实际无家可归的情况。
在75名患者中,19名(25%)患者的住房情况被其病例管理人员判定为不稳定。对大多数人来说,住房不稳定意味着居住安排的脆弱性,而非实际无家可归。不服药、酗酒和阴性症状占住房不稳定差异的30%。在随访期间,与居住稳定的患者相比,住房不稳定的患者再次住院的可能性并不更高,但被监禁的可能性略高,实际无家可归的可能性显著更高。
在作者之前对城市精神病患者的研究中,与住房不稳定的农村患者相比,住房不稳定的患者在随访期间更有可能实际无家可归、症状严重且再次住院。农村地区较好的结果似乎与更多的住房选择和强化病例管理有关。对于两种环境中住房不稳定的患者,应果断解决不服药、药物滥用以及住房安排等问题。